This application is the U.S. National Phase under 35 U.S.C. §371 of International Application No. PCT/JP2009/004976, filed on Sep. 29, 2009, which in turn claims the benefit of Japanese Application No. 2008-256027, filed on Oct. 1, 2008, the disclosures of which Applications are incorporated by reference herein.
The present invention relates to a nonvolatile memory element. More particularly, the present invention relates to a resistance variable nonvolatile memory element which changes its resistance value in response to electric signals applied, a manufacturing method thereof, and a manufacturing method of a nonvolatile semiconductor device incorporating the nonvolatile memory elements.
With recent advancement of digital technologies, electronic hardware such as portable information devices and home information appliances have been developed to provide higher functionality. For this reason, demands for an increase in a capacity of nonvolatile memory elements, reduction in a write electric power in the memory elements, reduction in write/read time in the memory elements, and longer life of the memory elements have been increasing.
Under the circumstances in which there are such demands, it is said that there is a limitation on miniaturization of the existing flash memory using a floating gate. On the other hand, a nonvolatile memory element (resistance variable memory) using a resistance variable layer as a material of a memory section is formed by a memory element having a simple structure including a resistance variable element. Therefore, further miniaturization, a higher-speed, and lower electric power consumption of the nonvolatile memory elements are expected.
When using the resistance variable layer as the material of the memory section, its resistance value changes from a high-resistance value to a low-resistance value or from the low-resistance value to the high-resistance value, for example, by applying electric pulses thereto. In this case, it is necessary to clearly distinguish two values, which are the high-resistance value and the low-resistance value, to change the resistance value stably between the low-resistance value and the high-resistance value at a high-speed, and to retain these two values in a nonvolatile manner. For the purpose of stabilization of such memory characteristics and miniaturization of memory elements, a variety of proposals have been made in the past.
As one of such proposals, patent document 1 discloses memory elements in which memory cells are formed by resistance variable elements each of which includes two electrodes and a storing layer sandwiched between these electrodes and is configured to reversibly change a resistance value of the storing layer.
As shown in
Each resistance variable element 10 is disposed above a MOS transistor 18 formed on a semiconductor substrate 11. The MOS transistor 18 includes source/drain regions 13 formed in a region isolated by an element isolating layer 12 inside the semiconductor substrate 11 and a gate electrode 14. The gate electrode 14 also serves as a word line which is one address wire of the memory element.
One of the source/drain regions 13 of the MOS transistor 18 is electrically connected to the lower electrode 1 of the resistance variable element 10 via a plug layer 15, a metal wire layer 16, and a plug layer 17. The other of the source/drain regions 13 of the MOS transistor 18 is connected to the metal wire layer 16 via the plug layer 15. The metal wire layer 16 is connected to a bit line which is the other address wire of the memory element.
By applying electric potentials with different polarities between the lower electrode 1 and the upper electrode 4 of the resistance variable element 10 configured as described above, ion source of the ion source layer 3 forming the storing layer is caused to migrate to the high-resistance layer 2. Or, the ion source is caused to migrate from the high-resistance layer 2 to the upper electrode 4. Thereby, the resistance value of the resistance variable element 10 changes from a high-resistance state value to a low-resistance state value, or from the low-resistance state value to the high-resistance state value, so that data is stored.
Examples using binary transition metal oxides which are different from the resistance variable materials disclosed in Patent document 1 are reported. For example, Patent document 2 discloses as resistance variable materials, NiO, V2O5, ZnO, Nb2O5, TiO2, WO3, and CoO.
However, oxygen in a transition metal oxide forming a resistance variable layer thermally diffuses under the influence of a thermal budget (total heat applied thereto) after forming the resistance variable layer. For this reason, an oxygen concentration profile of the resistance variable layer changes after forming the resistance variable layer.
When the post-process temperature increases only by 50 degrees C., the initial resistance of the resistance variable layer decreases a single digit or larger. Thus, the initial resistance of the resistance variable layer significantly depends on the post-process temperature. A cause of this may be that oxygen thermally diffuses in the above described transition metal oxide forming the resistance variable layer due to a post-process step which is a process step after forming the resistance variable layer. A temperature range of 350 degrees C.˜400 degrees C. is used in a wiring step in the existing semiconductor process, and a decrease in the initial resistance due to the diffusion of oxygen occurs inevitably. A change in the initial resistance affects a voltage at which the resistance changing operation starts. Therefore, to implement a nonvolatile memory element using a resistance variable layer as a material of a memory section and a stable operation of a nonvolatile semiconductor device (ReRAM) incorporating the nonvolatile memory element, it is very important to control the oxygen concentration profile of the transition metal oxide forming the resistance variable layer.
A multi-layer cross-point ReRAM includes plural memory array layers each including nonvolatile memory elements arranged in matrix. As the stacked layers increases in number, the thermal budget applied to the resistance variable layers correspondingly increases. Since the thermal budget applied is different between an upper resistance variable layer and a lower resistance variable layer in a multi-layer cross-point ReRAM, the oxygen concentration profile is different between the upper resistance variable layer and the lower resistance variable layer.
The present invention has been developed under the circumstances, and an object of the present invention is to provide a nonvolatile memory element which is high in heat resistance and includes a resistance variable layer with a desired oxygen concentration profile even after the resistance variable layer goes through a semiconductor process step, and a nonvolatile memory device including the nonvolatile memory element.
To solve the above described problem, a nonvolatile memory element of the present invention comprises a substrate; a first electrode formed on the substrate; a resistance variable layer formed on the first electrode; and a second electrode formed on the resistance variable layer. The resistance variable layer has a multi-layer structure including at least three layers which are a first transition metal oxide layer, a second transition metal oxide layer which is higher in oxygen concentration than the first transition metal oxide layer, and a transition metal oxynitride layer. The second transition metal oxide layer is in contact with either one of the first electrode and the second electrode. The transition metal oxynitride layer is provided between the first transition metal oxide layer and the second transition metal oxide layer.
Thereby, it is possible to obtain a resistance variable layer having a desired oxygen concentration profile even after the resistance variable layer is subjected to a thermal budget in a post-process step which is a process step after forming the resistance variable layer.
In the nonvolatile memory element, the transition metal oxynitride layer may serve as an oxygen diffusion barrier layer for suppressing diffusion of oxygen from the second transition metal oxide layer to the first transition metal oxide layer.
In the nonvolatile memory element, each of the first transition metal oxide layer and the second transition metal oxide layer may comprise tantalum oxide, and the transition metal oxynitride layer may comprise tantalum oxynitride. Since tantalum is a metal used in the existing semiconductor process, the nonvolatile memory element of the present invention is highly compatible with the semiconductor process.
A method of manufacturing a nonvolatile memory element of the present invention comprises the steps of: forming a first electrode on a substrate; forming a first transition metal oxide layer on the first electrode; forming a transition metal oxynitride layer on the first transition metal oxide layer; forming a second transition metal oxide layer on the transition metal oxynitride layer, the second transition metal oxide layer being higher in oxygen concentration than the first transition metal oxide layer; and forming a second electrode on the second transition metal oxide layer; wherein a resistance variable layer is formed to include the first transition metal oxide layer, the transition metal oxynitride layer and the second transition metal oxide layer.
Another method of manufacturing a nonvolatile memory element of the present invention comprises the steps of: forming a first electrode on a substrate; forming a second transition metal oxide layer on the first electrode; forming a transition metal oxynitride layer on the second transition metal oxide layer; forming a first transition metal oxide layer on the transition metal oxynitride layer, the first transition metal oxide layer being lower in oxygen concentration than the second transition metal oxide layer; and forming a second electrode on the first transition metal oxide layer; wherein a resistance variable layer is formed to include the second transition metal oxide layer, the transition metal oxynitride layer and the first transition metal oxide layer.
In the method of manufacturing the nonvolatile memory element, the transition metal oxynitride layer may be formed by a reactive sputtering process using a transition metal target and using an oxygen gas and a nitrogen gas as reactive gases. In the method of forming the transition metal oxynitride layer by the reactive sputtering process, since a vacuum system is used, the transition metal oxynitride layer is not affected by a natural oxide layer, and nitriding and oxidation can be performed concurrently. Therefore, the composition of the transition metal oxynitride layer can be easily controlled.
In the method of manufacturing the nonvolatile memory element, the transition metal oxynitride layer may be formed by thermally treating the first transition metal oxide layer under a nitrogen-containing atmosphere. Since the deposition speed of the transition metal oxynitride by the reactive sputtering process is as high as about 1 nm/sec, it is difficult to control a several-nm layer thickness. By performing thermal treatment under the nitrogen-containing atmosphere, it is easy to control the thickness of the transition metal oxynitride layer even when the transition metal oxynitride layer is a thin layer with a thickness of about several nm which is controlled with difficulty in the reactive sputtering process.
In the method of manufacturing the nonvolatile memory element, the transition metal oxynitride layer may be formed by plasma-nitriding the first transition metal oxide layer under a nitrogen plasma atmosphere. This makes it easy to control the thickness of the transition metal oxynitride layer even when the transition metal oxynitride layer is a thin layer with a thickness of about several nm which is controlled with difficulty in the reactive sputtering process. Furthermore, the transition metal oxynitride layer can be formed at a lower temperature than in a case where it is formed by thermal treatment under a nitrogen-containing atmosphere.
A nonvolatile semiconductor device of the present invention comprises a substrate; and a memory array including: a plurality of lower wires formed on the substrate to extend in parallel with each other; a plurality of upper wires which are formed above the plurality of lower wires to extend in parallel with each other within a plane parallel to a main surface of the substrate and three-dimensionally cross the plurality of lower wires, respectively; and nonvolatile memory elements which are provided to respectively correspond to three-dimensional cross-points of the plurality of lower wires and the plurality of upper wires; wherein each of the nonvolatile memory elements includes an upper electrode, a lower electrode, and a resistance variable layer, the resistance variable layer has a multi-layer structure including at least three layers which are a first transition metal oxide layer, a second transition metal oxide layer which is higher in oxygen content than the first transition metal oxide layer, and a transition metal oxynitride layer; wherein the second transition metal oxide layer is in contact with either one of the lower electrode and the upper electrode; wherein the transition metal oxynitride layer is provided between the first transition metal oxide layer and the second transition metal oxide layer; and wherein each of the nonvolatile memory elements includes a current controlling element which is electrically connected to the resistance variable layer.
The nonvolatile semiconductor device may further comprise: one or more constituent units being stacked together, the constituent units each including a memory array including the nonvolatile memory elements and the plurality of upper wires.
Thereby, it is possible to achieve a nonvolatile semiconductor device which has a maximized storing surface density. Since the transition metal oxynitride layer serves as an oxygen diffusion barrier layer, diffusion of oxygen which would occur under the influence of thermal budget is suppressed. Further, it is possible to provide a nonvolatile semiconductor device including resistance variable layers having a desired oxygen concentration profile even if the thermal budget increases, by further stacking the constituent units in one or more layers.
The above object, other objects, features, and advantages of the present invention will be apparent by the following detailed description of preferred embodiment of the inventions, with reference to the accompanying drawings.
In accordance with the present invention, it is possible to provide a nonvolatile memory element which is high in heat resistance and includes a resistance variable layer having a desired oxygen concentration profile even after the resistance variable layer is subjected to a thermal budget in a semiconductor process step, and a nonvolatile memory device including the nonvolatile memory element.
Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the drawings. Throughout the drawings, the same reference numerals are assigned to the same or corresponding parts and description thereof is omitted in some cases.
As shown in
The transition metal oxynitride layer 105 serves as a barrier for preventing oxygen from diffusing from the second transition metal oxide layer 106 to the first transition metal oxide layer 104. This enables the resistance variable layer 108 to have a desired oxygen concentration profile even after the resistance variable layer 108 is subjected to a thermal budget in a process step after forming the resistance variable layer 108.
It should be noted that in the present invention, a nonvolatile memory element having a structure in which the positional relationship of the upper and lower constituent layers of the resistance variable layer 108 shown in
The first transition metal oxide layer 104 and the second transition metal oxide layer 106 each desirably includes a transition metal oxide so that the resistance value changes upon application of voltages to the nonvolatile memory element. More desirably, the first transition metal oxide layer 104 and the second transition metal oxide layer 106 are made of a transition metal oxide. Most desirably, the first transition metal oxide layer 104 and the second transition metal oxide layer 106 are made of a transition metal oxygen-deficient oxide (oxide which is deficient in oxygen content in terms of a stoichiometric composition: for example, tantalum oxide which satisfies 0<x<2.5 in TaOx).
As the first transition metal oxide layer 104, tantalum oxide having a composition expressed as TaOx satisfying, for example, 0.8≦x≦1.9 may be used. As the second transition metal oxide layer 106, tantalum oxide having a composition expressed as TaOy satisfying, for example, 2.1≦y<2.5 may be used. In such a configuration, redox reaction selectively occurs between the first transition metal oxide layer 104 and the second transition metal oxide layer 106 and the resistance changes stably, upon application of voltages to the resistance variable element.
Suitably, the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 (oxygen diffusion barrier layer) suitably suppress migration (thermal diffusion) of oxygen due to heat which is 500 degree C. or lower, but allows oxygen to migrate therethrough during the resistance changing operation occurring by application of the voltages to the resistance variable element. As the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 having such a characteristic, tantalum oxynitride which does not have a stoichiometric composition is suitable. As used herein, the tantalum oxynitride having a stoichiometric composition is expressed as TaON because tantalum is pentavalent, oxygen is dyad and nitrogen is triad. When the composition of the tantalum oxynitride which does not have a stoichiometric composition as the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 is expressed as TaOx′Nz, it is desirable to satisfy 2x′+3z<5. The ratio between oxygen and nitrogen is not limited.
Examples of the first transition metal oxide layer 104, the second transition metal oxide layer 106 and the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 may be tantalum oxide, and tantalum oxynitride, but are not limited to these. Transition metals other than tantalum, for example, hafnium and zirconium allow an oxygen concentration profile to be effectively controlled in the same manner.
When hafnium oxides is used as the first metal oxide layer and the second transition metal oxide layer, 1.8<y<2.0 and 0.9≦x≦1.6 are desirably satisfied when the composition of the first metal oxide layer and the composition of the second metal oxide layer are expressed as HfOx and HfOy, respectively. As the transition metal oxynitride layer 105, hafnium oxynitride which does not have a stoichiometric composition is suitable. That is, when the composition of the hafnium oxynitride as the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 is expressed as HfOx′Nz, 2x′+3z<4 is desirably satisfied.
When zirconium oxide is used as the first metal oxide layer and the second transition metal oxide layer, 1.9<y<2.0 and 0.9≦x≦1.4 are desirably satisfied when the composition of the first metal oxide layer and the composition of the second metal oxide layer are expressed as ZrOx and ZrOy, respectively. As the transition metal oxynitride layer 105, zirconium oxynitride which does not have a stoichiometric composition is suitable. In other words, when the composition of the zirconium oxynitride as the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 is expressed as ZrOx′NZ, 2x′+3z<4 is desirably satisfied.
The above compositions can be measured using Rutherford Backscattering Spectrometry (RBS).
The transition metal oxynitride layer impedes thermal diffusion of oxygen, because the diffusion speed of oxygen ions significantly decreases and passivation of the oxygen ions occurs due to an event that nitrogen atoms compensate for oxygen ion vacancies and form pairs with interstitial oxygen ions. Therefore, in principle, transition metal oxynitrides other than tantalum oxynitride can effectively suppress thermal diffusion of oxygen like this embodiment.
[Manufacturing Method of Nonvolatile Memory Element]
Subsequently, the manufacturing method of the nonvolatile memory element 100 illustrated in
Initially, as shown in
Then, as shown in
Alternatively, the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 may be formed in such a manner that the second transition metal oxide layer 104 is thermally treated under a nitrogen-containing atmosphere after the transition metal oxide layer 104 is formed, or the transition metal oxynitride layer 104 may be formed by plasma nitriding using nitrogen plasma.
The deposition of the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 by the reactive sputtering process has an advantage that the content of oxygen and the content of nitrogen in the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 are easily controlled. The formation of the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 by the thermal treatment under the nitrogen-containing atmosphere or by plasma nitriding has an advantage that the thickness of the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 which is several-nm thick is easily controlled. The plasma nitriding has an advantage that the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 can be formed at a lower temperature than it is formed by thermal treatment under the nitrogen-containing atmosphere.
Then, as shown in
The resistance variable layer 108 composed of the first transition metal oxide layer 104, the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 and the second transition metal oxide layer 106 has a thickness of 30 nm˜100 nm.
As shown in
Finally, as shown in
Although the manufacturing method of the nonvolatile memory element 100 shown in
[Oxygen Diffusion in Nonvolatile Memory Element (Barrier Layer is not Present)]
Subsequently, thermal diffusion of oxygen from the second transition metal oxide layer 106 to the first transition metal oxide layer 104 in the resistance variable layer 108 of this embodiment will be described.
As shown in
When comparison is made between the oxygen concentration profile before thermal treatment and the oxygen concentration profile after thermal treatment, it is observed that the peak intensity of oxygen in the high-oxygen-concentration region 301 (corresponding to the second transition metal oxide layer 106) decreased and the peak intensity of oxygen in the low-oxygen-concentration region 302 (corresponding to the first transition metal oxide layer 104) increased after the thermal treatment. This implies that oxygen in the second transition metal oxide layer 106 diffused to the first transition metal oxide layer 104 due to the thermal treatment.
[Oxygen Diffusion in Nonvolatile Memory Element (Barrier Layer is Present)]
As can be seen from the results of
Hafnium oxide and hafnium oxynitride, or zirconium oxide and zirconium oxynitride can be deposited by the reactive sputtering process using a transition metal target and a sputtering gas which is a mixture of argon gas and oxygen or nitrogen, as in the case of tantalum. The resistivities and thicknesses of these compounds can be measured by a method similar to the method for tantalum.
[Resistance Variable Element Initial Resistance after Thermal Treatment]
As can be seen from
The reason why the resistance value decreases due to the fact that the resistance variable layer 108 goes through the thermal treatment step may possibly be that oxygen diffuses to platinum used as the second electrode as well as oxygen diffusion from the second transition metal oxide layer 106 to the first transition metal oxide layer 104. Since platinum is a metal which allows oxygen to migrate therethrough relatively easily, the resistance value of the resistance variable layer 108 decreases by an event that a part of oxygen in the second transition metal oxide layer 106 migrates toward platinum.
The resistance value of the resistance variable layer after the thermal treatment is not determined only by the diffusion of oxygen from the second transition metal oxide layer 106 to the first transition metal oxide layer 104. Nonetheless, by increasing the thickness of the transition metal oxynitride layer 105, it is possible to more effectively suppress the oxygen diffusion effect from the second transition metal oxide layer 106 to the first transition metal oxide layer 104 and thereby to lessen a decrease rate of the initial resistance of the resistance variable layer 108 after the thermal treatment. In other words, the thermal diffusion of oxygen from the second transition metal oxide layer 106 is suppressed by the oxygen barrier effect of the transition metal oxynitride layer 105, and thereby a decrease rate of the resistance value due to the thermal treatment is suppressed.
[Resistance Changing Operation of Nonvolatile Memory Element]
From the results of
It should be noted that the above mentioned resistance changing characteristic of the nonvolatile memory element shown in
[Explanation of Resistance Changing Operation]
As shown in
In the above structure, upon application of voltages to the nonvolatile memory element 100, oxygen ions migrate between the second transition metal oxide layer 106 and the first transition metal oxide layer 104 via the transition metal oxynitride layer 105 (oxygen diffusion barrier layer). For example, upon application of a negative voltage pulse to the nonvolatile memory element 100, oxygen migrates from the second metal oxide layer 106 to the first metal oxide layer 104, so that the oxygen content of the second transition metal oxide layer 106 in the high-resistance state decreases and the resistance value of the second transition metal oxide layer 106 is lowered. As a result, the nonvolatile memory element 100 is placed into the low-resistance state.
[Influence of Oxygen Diffusion Barrier Layer During Resistance Changing Operation]
As shown in
The above described nonvolatile memory element of Embodiment 1 is applicable to so-called a multi-layer cross-point nonvolatile semiconductor device in which memory arrays each including a plurality of lower wires, a plurality of upper wires crossing the lower wires, respectively, and the nonvolatile memory elements arranged at cross points of the upper wires and the lower wires are three-dimensionally stacked together to form a multi-layer structure. This will be described below.
[Explanation of Multi-Layer Cross-Point ReRAM]
Although in the example of
[Configuration of Nonvolatile Memory Element Included in Nonvolatile Semiconductor Device of Embodiment 2]
As shown in
Since voltages with different polarities are applied to the resistance variable layer 206, a diode composed of the lower electrode 203, the current controlling element 204 and the inner electrode 205 is required to be a bidirectional diode having a current steering property with respect to applied voltages with different polarities. For this reason, the diode composed of the lower electrode 203, the current controlling element 204 and the inner electrode 205 may be a MSM diode in which the current controlling element 204 is a semiconductor, or a MIM diode in which the current controlling element 204 is an insulator. In such a configuration, it is possible to achieve a nonvolatile memory element which can prevent cross talk due to a leak current from unselected memory cells other than a memory cell (selected memory cell) for which reading and writing is performed, while flowing a sufficient current to the selected memory cell when reading and writing is performed, and has high reproducibility in resistance changing characteristic and high reliability.
The inner electrode 205, the resistance variable layer 206 and the upper electrode 207 correspond to the first electrode 103, the resistance variable layer 108 and the second electrode layer 107 in the nonvolatile memory element 100 according to Embodiment 1 shown in
In a semiconductor process step, it is necessary to increase the temperature up to 350 degrees C. or higher in a step for forming wires and up to about 400 degrees C. in a step for forming an interlayer insulating layer between lower wires and upper wires, every time one layer of a memory array and wire layers is formed. For this reason, in a multi-layer cross point nonvolatile semiconductor device, a thermal budget applied to a nonvolatile memory element in a lower layer is different from a thermal budget applied to a nonvolatile memory element in an upper layer. Since an average diffusion distance of oxygen correlates with the thermal budget, there is a difference in oxygen concentration profile between the resistance variable layer 206 in a lower layer and the resistance variable layer 206 in an upper layer, in the multi-layer cross-point nonvolatile semiconductor device.
However, by using the nonvolatile semiconductor device having the configuration of this Embodiment, the transition metal oxynitride layer 209 serves as the oxygen diffusion barrier layer to suppress thermal diffusion of oxygen in the resistance variable layer 206 including the transition metal oxynitride layer 209, as should be clear from the description in Embodiment 1. Therefore, in a case where a multi-layer cross point nonvolatile semiconductor device is manufactured, it is possible to form a resistance variable layer having a designed oxygen concentration profile for every individual nonvolatile memory element.
Numerous modifications and alternative embodiments of the invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art in view of the foregoing description. Accordingly, the description is to be construed as illustrative only, and is provided for the purpose of teaching those skilled in the art the best mode of carrying out the invention. The details of the structure and/or function may be varied substantially without departing from the spirit of the invention.
A nonvolatile memory element and nonvolatile memory device of the present invention are useful as a nonvolatile memory element and nonvolatile memory device including the nonvolatile memory element, which have high heat resistance and include a resistance variable layer having a desired oxygen concentration profile even after the resistance variable layer is subjected to a thermal budget in a semiconductor process step.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
2008-256027 | Oct 2008 | JP | national |
Filing Document | Filing Date | Country | Kind | 371c Date |
---|---|---|---|---|
PCT/JP2009/004976 | 9/29/2009 | WO | 00 | 6/1/2010 |
Publishing Document | Publishing Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
WO2010/038423 | 4/8/2010 | WO | A |
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
20010055838 | Walker et al. | Dec 2001 | A1 |
20040235200 | Hsu et al. | Nov 2004 | A1 |
20040245557 | Seo et al. | Dec 2004 | A1 |
20050247921 | Lee et al. | Nov 2005 | A1 |
20060011897 | Hsu et al. | Jan 2006 | A1 |
20060166476 | Lee et al. | Jul 2006 | A1 |
20070114587 | Seo et al. | May 2007 | A1 |
20080083918 | Aratani et al. | Apr 2008 | A1 |
20090014710 | Kawashima et al. | Jan 2009 | A1 |
20090230376 | Ryoo et al. | Sep 2009 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
2004-349690 | Dec 2004 | JP |
2004-363604 | Dec 2004 | JP |
2005-317976 | Nov 2005 | JP |
2006-040946 | Feb 2006 | JP |
2008-512857 | Apr 2008 | JP |
2008-244397 | Oct 2008 | JP |
2009-021524 | Jan 2009 | JP |
2009-049183 | Mar 2009 | JP |
2009-218260 | Sep 2009 | JP |
WO 2006029228 | Mar 2006 | WO |
WO 2007102483 | Sep 2007 | WO |
WO 2008050716 | May 2008 | WO |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20100308298 A1 | Dec 2010 | US |