Planarization system with multiple polishing pads

Information

  • Patent Grant
  • 6626744
  • Patent Number
    6,626,744
  • Date Filed
    Friday, April 21, 2000
    24 years ago
  • Date Issued
    Tuesday, September 30, 2003
    20 years ago
Abstract
An apparatus for simultaneously polishing wafers including at least a first and a second web of polishing media. At least two polishing heads are provided on a carrier coupled to a drive system such that one polishing head positions a wafer against the first web and a second polishing head positions a second wafer against the second web. The drive system imparts a programmed polishing motion or pattern to the polishing heads.
Description




BACKGROUND OF THE DISCLOSURE




1. Field of Invention




The present invention relates generally to a semiconductor wafer planarization system. More specifically, the invention relates to a planarization system having multiple polishing pads or webs.




2. Background of Invention




In semiconductor wafer processing, the use of chemical mechanical planarization, or CMP, has gained favor due to the enhanced ability to stack multiple devices on a semiconductor workpiece, or substrate, such as a wafer. As the demand for planarization of layers formed on wafers in semiconductor fabrication increases, the requirement for greater system (i.e., tool) throughput with less wafer damage and enhanced wafer planarization has also increased.




Two CMP systems that address these issues are described in a patent to Perlov et al. (U.S. Pat. No. 5,804,507, issued Sep. 8, 1998) and in a patent to Tolles et al. (U.S. Pat. No. 5,738,574, issued Apr. 15, 1998), both of which are hereby incorporated by reference. Perlov et al. and Tolles et al. disclose a CMP system having a planarization apparatus that is supplied wafers from cassettes located in an adjacent liquid filled bath. A transfer mechanism, or robot, facilitates the transfer of the wafers from the bath to a transfer station. From the transfer station, the wafers are loaded to one of four processing heads mounted to a carousel. The carousel moves the processing heads and wafers to various planarization stations where the wafers are planarized by moving the wafer relative to a polishing pad in the presence of a slurry or other fluid medium. The polishing pad may include an abrasive surface. Additionally, the slurry may contain both chemicals and abrasives that aid in the removal of material from the wafer. After completion of the planarization process, the wafer is returned back through the transfer station to the proper cassette located in the bath.




Another system is disclosed in a patent to Hoshizaki et al. (U.S. Pat. No. 5,908,530, issued Jun. 1, 1999) which is hereby incorporated by reference. Hoshizaki et al. teaches an apparatus for planarizing wafers wherein the wafer is subjected to uniform velocity across the wafer surface with respect to the abrasive surface. The uniform velocity across the wafer surface coupled with a multi-programable planarization pattern results in a uniform rate of material removal from the wafer surface. In addition, Hoshizaki et al. provides a number of optional routines that allow a user to fine tune material removal from the wafer.




Another system is disclosed by Sommer in a U.S. Patent Application No. 60/169,770 (filed Dec. 9, 1999 hereinafter referred to as “Sommer '770”) which is incorporated by reference in its entirety. Sommer '770 describes a planarization system comprising two polishing heads for retaining wafers coupled to a drive system disposed over a single web. By polishing two wafers simultaneously on a single web, the rate of wafer throughput is enhanced.




The systems described above can generally utilize polishing pads with and without abrasive finishes. The polishing pads may be stationary or move relative to the wafer, e.g., rotationally or linearly. Additionally, abrasive slurry, di-ionized water and other fluids may be moved to the polishing pad during the processing of the wafer.




One problem common to systems utilizing webs of polishing media is the difficulty in planarizing more than one wafer having a diameter of 300 mm (approximately 11{fraction (13/16)} inches). 300 mm wafers are becoming increasingly desirable due to the ability to produce a greater number of devices on a single wafer. Currently, webs utilized as polishing pads are only available in widths up to 37 inches. These webs additionally only have a usable polishing area of about 34 inches. This conventional pad width will accommodate a polishing process that positions two 200 mm wafers side-by-side across the width of the pad when polishing, however, this pad width is insufficient to allow two 300 mm disposed side-by-side across the width of the web to travel in a polishing pattern adequate to satisfactorily planarize the wafers. As such, conventional planarization systems are limited to planarizing a single wafer across the width of the web and correspondingly, cannot obtain throughputs comparable to 200 mm systems.




Therefore, there is a need for an apparatus that provides increased throughput of 300 mm wafers in a chemical mechanical wafer planarization system.




SUMMARY OF INVENTION




One aspect of the present invention provides a chemical mechanical planarization system for planarizing wafers having a multiple webs. Generally, the system comprises a base, a first web disposed over the base, a second web disposed over the base, and a carrier having a first polishing head and a second polishing head. The first polishing head is movably disposed over the first web and the second polishing head is movably disposed over the second web. A drive system operably couples the carrier to the base such that the drive system moves each polishing head relative the to respective web in unison.




In an exemplary embodiment, each polishing head is moved in a polishing pattern comprising a first motion provided by a first linear motion device, and a second motion substantially perpendicular to the first motion provided by a second motion device. The system polishes at least one wafer per width of web, thus allowing polishing patterns for larger wafers, i.e., 300 mm wafers, as well as multiple smaller wafers to be accommodated.











BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS




The teachings of the present invention can be readily understood by considering the following detailed description in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:





FIG. 1

is a schematic view of a chemical mechanical planarization system of the present invention;





FIG. 2

is a perspective view of a drive system of the chemical mechanical planarization system of

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 3

is a side elevation of the chemical mechanical planarization system of

FIG. 1

;





FIG. 4

is a cross sectional view of the drive system of

FIG. 3

taken along section line


4





4


.





FIG. 5

is a side elevation of another embodiment of a drive system; and





FIG. 6

is another embodiment of a chemical mechanical planarization system of the invention.











To facilitate understanding, identical reference numerals have been used, where possible, to designate identical elements that are common to the figures.




DETAIL DESCRIPTION OF INVENTION





FIG. 1

depicts a schematic view of a chemical mechanical planarization system


100


including multiple conditioning webs


108




a


and


108




b.


The system


100


generally comprises a front end


160


, a polishing media magazine


102


, a drive system


104


and a base


106


.




The front end


160


generally comprises a load station


180


, a cleaner


170


, and a robot


166


. The robot


166


is a conventional robot


166


commonly used to transfer substrates or wafers


126


into and out of and one or more wafer cassettes


168


. The typical robot


166


is a single blade robot having a vacuum gripper disposed at the end of a pair of extendable arms. By applying vacuum to the gripper, the wafer


126


is retained by the robot


166


for transfer between the cassettes


168


, the load station


180


, and the cleaner


170


.




The load station


180


generally comprises an edge grip robot


172


, one or more substrate supports


174


and a shuttle


162


. Unpolished wafers


126


retrieved from the cassette


168


by the robot


166


are set on the substrate support


174


. The edge grip robot


172


retrieves the wafer


126


from the substrate support


174


by gripping the substrate at its edge. The edge grip robot


172


transfers the wafer


126


between the substrate support


174


and the shuttle


162


.




The shuttle


162


is coupled to an actuator that permits the shuttle


162


to be selectively positioned between a first and second position. In the first position, the shuttle


162


receives the unpolished wafers


126


from the edge grip robot


172


into one of the one or more load cups


164


disposed on the shuttle


162


. In the second position, the shuttle


162


transfers the unpolished wafer


126


from the load cup


164


to the drive system


104


. The drive system


104


retains the wafer


126


during processing. Polished wafers return from the drive system


104


across the shuttle


162


in the opposite manner. An example of a shuttle table that may be adapted for use with the present invention is described in the previously incorporated U.S. patent application Sommer '770.




The polishing media magazine


102


generally comprises an unwind


110


and a winder


112


. Multiple webs of polishing media


108




a


and


108




b


are run between the unwind


110


and the winder


112


. Optionally, more than two webs of polishing media may by used. Typically a first web


108




a


of polishing media and a second web


108




b


of polishing media are run adjacent to each other between the unwind


110


and the winder


112


. Alternatively, each web


108




a


and


108




b


may be disposed between a dedicated (i.e., separate) winder


112


and unwind


110


. Each web (


108




a


and


108




b


) can be substantially “rolled-up” at either the unwind


110


or the winder


112


, or partially wound on both the unwind


110


and the winder


112


such that various portions of each web (


108




a


and


108




b


) may be selectively exposed between the unwind


110


and the winder


112


. Each web (


108




a


and


108




b


) may be indexed or advanced, individually or in unison.




A working region


116


of the first web


108




a


is disposed on a polishing surface


107


of the base


106


of the system


100


. The working region


116


of the first web


108




a


is orientated in relation to the base


106


such that a working surface


118


of the first web


108




a


is on the side of the first web


108




a


facing away from the base


106


. A working region


117


of the second web


108




b


is similarly disposed on the polishing surface of the base


106


. The working region


117


of the second web


108




b


is orientated in relation to the base


106


such that a working surface


119


of the second web


108




b


is on the side of the second web


108




b


facing away from the base


106


. Optionally, the working surfaces


118


and


119


may comprise an abrasive coating, a plurality of abrasive elements comprising abrasive articles disposed in a binder (e.g., fixed abrasive pad), finish, covering and/or texture. An example of such a polishing media magazine configured to handle a single web in which the aspects of the invention can be advantageously incorporated is described by Sommer in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 08/833,278 (filed Apr. 4, 1997 and hereinafter referred to as “Sommer '278”) which is incorporated by reference in its entirety.




The polishing media magazine


102


may further comprises a conditioning device


149


. The conditioning device


149


conditions (i.e., dresses) the working surfaces


118


and


119


of the webs to create a uniformly textured surface that removes material from the surface of the wafers at a uniform rate. In one embodiment, the conditioning device


149


comprises two rollers


150


rotating in opposing directions that are selectively placed in contact with the working surfaces (


118


and


119


) of each web to condition the working surfaces. Other types of conditioning devices may optionally be utilized alone or in conjunction with the rollers


150


. Examples of other conditioning devices include rotating disks, cylinders, rods and brushes, water jets, mega and ultrasonic devices. Additionally, the conditioning devices


149


may include conditioning elements having patterned surfaces or embossed surfaces, or surfaces containing oxides, ceramic or diamonds. Additional conditioning devices are also described by Sommer et al. in the previously incorporated U.S. Patent Application Ser. No. 60/172,416, filed Dec. 17, 1999.




The drive system


104


is coupled to the base


106


. The drive system


104


typically comprises a first linear motion device


120


, a second linear motion device


122


, a first polishing head


124


and a second polishing head


125


. The first polishing head


124


is movably positioned above the working region


116


of the first web


108




a


. The second polishing head


125


is movably positioned above the working region


117


of the second web


108




b.


The first linear motion device


120


and the second linear motion device


122


(which could be replaced by one device providing at least an equivalent range of motion) couples the polishing heads


124


and


125


to the base


106


. The linear motion devices


120


and


122


move the polishing heads


124


and


125


in a synchronous programmable pattern in relation to the base


106


. Optionally, more than one polishing head may be positioned along the length of the web. As one polishing head is disposed on a web width, large diameter wafers (i.e., 300 mm wafers) can be moved across the width of the web to travel in a polishing pattern that produces an advantageous planarized surface on the wafer. Additionally, the ability of the system to use a single drive system and multiple webs of polishing media to polish multiple wafers simultaneously provides greater wafer throughput as compared to systems that are limited to polishing one wafer at a time. The system


100


may also be configured to polish two wafers of smaller diameter across the width of each web (i.e., two wafers per web width) to provide greater throughput for systems planarizing wafers having a diameter less than 300 mm.





FIGS. 2

,


3


and


4


are a perspective view of the drive system


104


, a side elevation of the drive system


104


, and a cross sectional view of the side elevation of the drive system


104


, respectively. The first linear motion device


120


generally comprise a stage


202


, a roller bearing guide


204


and a driver


206


. The stage


202


is fabricated from aluminum or other light weight material. The stage


202


may comprise stiffening ribs to minimized the deflection in a direction normal the base


106


. The use of such light weight materials minimizes the inertia of the stage


202


that effects stage motion. The guide


204


is coupled to the stage


202


and interfaces with a rail


208


disposed upon a support


210


fixed to two sides of the base


106


. The guide


204


allows the stage


202


to move along the support


210


in a linear motion generally parallel to the length of the webs


108




a


and


108




b.


The guide


204


may alternatively comprise solid bearings, air bearings or similar devices to provide similar motion. The driver


206


provides motion to the stage


202


relative to the base


106


. The driver may comprise “Sawyer” motors, ball screws, cylinders, belts, rack and pinion gears, servo motors, stepper motors and other devices for creating and controlling linear motion. Generally, one portion of the driver


206


is connected to the support


210


while a second portion is connected to the stage


207


.




The second linear motion device


122


generally comprises a carrier


302


, a roller bearing guide


304


and a driver


306


. The carrier


302


is also fabricated from aluminum or other light weight material. The guide


304


is coupled to the carrier


302


and interfaces with a rail


212


disposed on the stage


202


. The guide


304


allows the carrier


302


to move along the stage


202


in a linear motion perpendicular to the motion of the stage. The guide


304


may alternatively comprise solid bearings, air bearings or similar devices. The driver


306


provides motion to the carrier


302


relative the stage


202


. The driver


306


may comprise “Sawyer” motors, ball screws, cylinders, belts, rack and pinion gears, servo motors, stepper motors and other devices for creating and controlling linear motion.




The carrier


302


further comprises the first polishing head


124


and the second polishing head


125


. The polishing heads


124


and


125


are coupled to the carrier


302


in a position such that the first polishing head


124


is disposed above the first web


108




a


and the second polishing head


125


is disposed above the second web


108




b.


Additional polishing heads may be incorporated such that all polishing heads residing above a web are orientated substantially along the length of the web. Each polishing head


124


and


125


are coupled to the carrier


302


via one or more actuators


308


that provide motion to the polishing heads (


124


and


125


) in a direction normal to the working surface


107


of the base


106


. The motion provided by the first and second linear motion devices (


120


and


122


) move the carrier


302


in an x/y motion relative the webs (


108




a


and


108




b


). The range of motion allows the wafer


126


disposed in the polishing heads


124


and


125


to contact the respective webs


108




a


and


108




b.






Alternatively, as depicted in

FIG. 5

, the second linear motion device


122


may comprise a third linear motion device


502


and a fourth linear motion device


504


. The third linear motion device


502


couples the first polishing head


124


to the first linear motion device


120


. The fourth linear motion device


504


couples the second polishing head


125


to the first linear motion device


120


. The third linear motion device


502


and the fourth linear motion device


504


may be programmed to move in unison or independently from one another such that one polishing head may be programmed to move in a polishing pattern independent from the other polishing head.




The exemplary system


100


of

FIG. 1

depicts the polishing heads (


124


and


125


) coupled to a carrier


302


disposed respectively over the first and second webs of polishing media (


108




a


and


108




b


) wherein the carrier is coupled to a drive system


104


that provides an x/y motion to the polishing heads relative the webs. However, the invention described herein is equally applicable to other drive systems including those in which wafers are moved rotationally over webs of polishing media (i.e., two polishing webs) and those in which the polishing media webs are moved under fixed wafers.





FIG. 6

depicts an embodiment of the present invention having a planarization system


600


incorporating a carrier in the form of a carousel


620


. The system


600


comprises a polishing media magazine


102


having a first web


108




a


and a second web


108




b


of polishing media disposed between an unwind


110


and winder


112


. The first and second web (


108




a


and


108




b


) are disposed atop a base


610


.




The base


610


comprises a top


608


that defines two or more substantially circular polishing stations


604


wherein at least one polishing station


614


is disposed atop the first web


108




a


and at least another polishing station


612


is disposed atop the second web


108




b.


The carousel


620


is centrally disposed atop the base


610


and has two or more arms


622


. Each arm supports a drive system


624


that operably couples a polishing head


604


to the arm


622


. The drive system


624


rotates the polishing head


604


and provides the polishing head


604


with a translation motion in relation to the webs


108




a


,


108




b.


Typically, the translational motion is provided long the axis of the arms


622


. Additionally, the drive system


624


actuates the polishing head


604


selectively against the polishing webs


108




a


,


108




b.






Each polishing head


604


is configured to retain the wafer


126


while polishing the wafer


126


in a predetermined polishing pattern. The polishing head


604


rotates while moving in a x/y-plane (i.e., the plane of the working surface of the polishing media). The wafer


126


is held against the working surface along a z-axis of the polishing head


604


. The rotation about the z-axis coupled with the movement in the x/y plane to create an planarization pattern between the wafer


126


and the webs


108




a


and


108




b


of polishing media. Optionally, the carousel


620


may be oscillated (i.e., rotate in one direction or back and forth about the center of the carousel) to polish the wafer


126


over a larger area of the webs


108




a


,


108




b.






Referring to

FIGS. 1 and 2

, in operation, the wafer


126


is retrieved from the wafer cassette


168


by the robot


166


. The robot


166


transfers the wafer


126


to the substrate support


174


. The edge grip robot


172


retrieves the wafer


126


and transfers the wafer to the load cup


164


. Typically, when the shuttle comprises more than one load cup


164


, additional wafers are placed in the other load cups


164


present on the shuttle


162


. The shuttle


162


moves the load cups


164


into the position below the polishing heads


124


and


125


. The load cups


164


raise the wafers


126


into the polishing heads


124


and


125


where they are retained for processing. Alternatively, the polishing heads may actuate downward to receive the wafer from a stationary load cup or the polishing heads and load cups may both move towards each other. The load cups


164


move clear from the polishing heads


124


and


125


. The shuttle


162


moves from under the polishing heads


124


and


125


.




The polishing heads


124


and


125


are lowered to contact wafers


126


disposed in the polishing heads with the respective working surfaces


118


and


119


of the first and second webs


108




a


and


108




b.


Wafers


126


disposed in the polishing heads


124


and


125


are set in motion relative to the working surfaces


118


and


119


. A polishing fluid provided through nozzles


190


can be disposed between the wafers


126


and the working surfaces


118


and


119


to facilitate material removal from a feature side of the wafers


126


in contact with the first and second webs


108




a


and


108




b.


Polishing fluids may contain abrasive particles. Generally, the particular polishing fluid is selected with regard to the substrate material to be polished and the type of polishing pad to be used. Examples of polishing fluids include de-ionized water, ammonium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, oxidizers, complexing agents, inhibitors, solubizers, buffers, abrasive slurry or any combination thereof.




For example, when polishing copper using a fixed abrasive pad, the polishing fluid generally includes an oxidizer that forms CuO on the surface of the copper. A complexing agent in the polishing fluid, such as NH


3


, bonds with the CuO to form Cu(NH


4


)


1-6


. Additionally, an inhibitor, such as BTA, is provided that also bonds with the CuO, competing with the completing agent for sites on the CucO surface. As Cu(NH


4


)


1-6


is relatively soluble, this compound moves from the surface of the copper and into solution, while the BTA-CuO compound remains relatively stable on the surface of the copper. Thus rate of chemical removal of copper from the surface may be controller by controlling the ratio of the inhibitors to complexing agents.




Once polishing is complete, the polishing heads


124


and


125


lift the polished wafers


126


clear of the webs


108




a


and


108




b.


The shuttle


162


again moves beneath the polishing heads


124


and


125


and retrieves the polished wafers


126


into the load cups


164


. The shuttle


162


moves clear of the polishing heads


124


and


125


, and the edge grip robot


172


transfers the polished wafer


126


to the substrate support


174


. The robot


166


transfers the polished wafers


126


from the substrate support


174


to the cleaner


170


where slurry and other contaminants are removed from the surface of the polished wafer


126


. While the polished wafer


126


is being cleaned, the shuttle


162


is free to move other unpolished wafers from the cassettes


168


to the polishing heads


124


and


125


. Once the polished wafer


126


is clean, the robot


166


transfers the cleaned wafer


126


from the cleaner


170


to the cassettes


168


. It is believed that as the system employs multiple webs to polish more than one wafer simultaneously, greater throughput and reduced cost of ownership can be realized over systems that polish one wafer at a time.




Although the teachings of the present invention that have been shown and described in detail herein, those skilled in the art can readily devise other varied embodiments that still incorporate the teachings and do not depart from the spirit of the invention.



Claims
  • 1. A semiconductor wafer planarization system for processing a wafer comprising:a base; a first web disposed over the base; a second web disposed over the base, the second web advanceable independently from the first web; a carrier having a first polishing head and a second polishing head, the first polishing head movably disposed over the first web, the second polishing head movably disposed over the second web; and a drive system operably coupling the carrier to the base.
  • 2. The planarization system of claim 1, wherein the drive system further comprises:a first linear motion device movably coupled to the base; and a second linear motion device movably coupled to the first linear motion device, wherein the second linear motion device is coupled to the carrier.
  • 3. The planarization system of claim 2, wherein the first web and the second web are disposed between at least a winder and an unwind, the first web and the second web capable of being indexed or advanced between the winder and the unwind.
  • 4. The planarization system of claim 2 further comprising one or more conditioning devices selectively disposed against the first and the second web.
  • 5. The planarization system of claim 1, wherein the carrier further comprises:a first carrier supporting the first polishing head; and, a second carrier supporting the second polishing head.
  • 6. The planarization system of claim 1 further comprising:a first linear motion device movably coupled to the base; and a second linear motion device comprising: a third linear motion device movably coupled to the first linear motion device, the second linear motion device supporting the first carrier; and a fourth linear motion device movably coupled to the first linear motion device, the fourth linear motion device supporting the second carrier.
  • 7. The planarization system of claim 5, wherein the first web and the second web are disposed between a winder and an unwind, the first web and the second web capable of being indexed or advanced between the winder and the unwind.
  • 8. The planarization system of claim 5 further comprising a conditioning device selectively disposed against the first and the second web.
  • 9. The planarization system of claim 1 further comprising a nozzle for disposing a polishing fluid on the first and the second web.
  • 10. The planarization system of claim 9, wherein the polishing fluid is comprised of a fluid selected from the group of de-ionized water, ammonium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, oxidizers, complexing agents, inhibitors, solubizers, buffers, abrasive slurry or any combination thereof.
  • 11. A semiconductor wafer planarization system for processing a wafer comprising:a polishing media magazine comprising: a first web of polishing media; and a second web of polishing media, the second web of polishing media advanceable independently from the first web of polishing media; a base having a polishing surface upon which a portion of the first web and the second web of polishing media are disposed; a drive system comprising: a first linear motion device movably coupled to the base; and a second linear motion device movably coupled to the first linear motion device; a first polishing head coupled to the second linear motion device and disposed over the first web; and a second polishing head coupled to the second linear motion device and disposed over the second polishing web.
  • 12. The semiconductor wafer planarization system of claim 11, wherein the polishing media magazine further comprises one or more conditioning devices that selectively contact the first and the second web.
  • 13. The semiconductor wafer planarization system of claim 11 further comprising:a nozzle for disposing a polishing fluid on the first and the second web; and wherein the polishing fluid is comprised of a fluid selected from the group of de-ionized water, ammonium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, oxidizers, complexing agents, inhibitors, solubizers, buffers, abrasive slurry or any combination thereof.
  • 14. The planarization system of claim 2 further comprising:a third polishing head coupled to the carrier and disposed above the first web; and a fourth polishing head coupled to the carrier and disposed above the second web.
  • 15. The semiconductor wafer planarization system of claim 11, wherein the drive system further comprises:a third polishing head coupled to the second linear motion device and disposed over the first web, and a fourth polishing head coupled to the second linear motion device and disposed over the second polishing web.
  • 16. The semiconductor wafer planarization system of claim 11, wherein the polishing media magazine further comprises:a third web disposed on the base; and wherein the drive system further comprises: a third polishing head coupled to the second linear motion device and disposed over the third web.
CROSS REFERENCE TO OTHER RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is related to U.S. patent application Ser. Nos. 08/961,602, 08/833,278, U.S. Patent Application Ser. No. 60/172,416, all of which are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.

US Referenced Citations (39)
Number Name Date Kind
4347689 Hammond Sep 1982 A
4642943 Taylor, Jr. Feb 1987 A
5065547 Shimizu et al. Nov 1991 A
5088240 Ruble et al. Feb 1992 A
5099615 Ruble et al. Mar 1992 A
5209027 Ishida et al. May 1993 A
5220750 Emberland et al. Jun 1993 A
5276999 Bando Jan 1994 A
5335453 Baldy et al. Aug 1994 A
5399125 Dozier Mar 1995 A
5443415 Shebanow et al. Aug 1995 A
5476413 Hasegawa et al. Dec 1995 A
5487697 Jensen Jan 1996 A
5490808 Jantschek et al. Feb 1996 A
5558568 Talieh et al. Sep 1996 A
5593344 Weldon et al. Jan 1997 A
5660581 Shin et al. Aug 1997 A
5676590 Hiraoka Oct 1997 A
5692947 Talieh et al. Dec 1997 A
5704827 Nishi et al. Jan 1998 A
5722877 Meyer et al. Mar 1998 A
5762536 Pant et al. Jun 1998 A
5800248 Pant et al. Sep 1998 A
5871390 Pant et al. Feb 1999 A
5897426 Somekh Apr 1999 A
5899801 Tolles et al. May 1999 A
5913716 Mucci et al. Jun 1999 A
5997384 Blalock Dec 1999 A
6059643 Hu et al. May 2000 A
6089962 Spinasse Jul 2000 A
6103628 Talieh Aug 2000 A
6123607 Ravkin et al. Sep 2000 A
6193588 Carlson et al. Feb 2001 B1
6196896 Sommer Mar 2001 B1
6196899 Chopra et al. Mar 2001 B1
6241583 White Jun 2001 B1
6244935 Birang et al. Jun 2001 B1
6250994 Chopra et al. Jun 2001 B1
6379231 Birang et al. Apr 2002 B1
Foreign Referenced Citations (6)
Number Date Country
0 756 917 Feb 1997 EP
0 818 272 Jan 1998 EP
62-162466 Jul 1987 JP
2-269553 Nov 1990 JP
4-250967 Sep 1992 JP
7-111256 Apr 1995 JP
Provisional Applications (1)
Number Date Country
60/172416 Dec 1999 US