The present technology relates to a high sensitivity sensor. More specifically, the present technology relates to a high sensitivity photodetector with a high-gain transimpedance amplifier.
Monitoring electrical activity and Ca2+ transients in biological tissues and individual cells increasingly utilizes optical sensors based on voltage-dependent and Ca2+ dependent fluorescent dyes. However, achieving satisfactory signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) often requires increased illumination intensities and/or dye concentrations, which results in photo-toxicity, photobleaching, and other adverse effects limiting the utility of optical recordings. Most challenging are the recordings from individual cardiac myocytes and neurons.
Current transimpedance amplifiers used to amplify fluorescent signals from individual cells are insufficiently sensitive, while other types of single-channel photodetectors are prohibitively expensive. High-gain transimpedance amplifiers rely on a high-impedance (>1 GΩ) resistive element in the feedback path to achieve high gain. The key issues that diminish their performance in photo detection are parasitic capacitance, which makes it difficult to achieve the same bandwidth from one circuit to another, cross-talk and capacitive coupling (high-impedance circuits are by nature very susceptible to coupling from or to neighboring circuits), and the difficulty in optimizing the circuit elements to minimize noise (every noise source in the circuit will have a weighted contribution, and therefore none can be neglected). Thus, there is a need for an low-cost, high-sensitivity photodetector incorporating a high-gain transimpedance amplifier.
The present technology is directed to overcoming these and other deficiencies in the art.
One aspect of the present technology relates to a device. The device includes a sensor having an anode and a cathode. An operational amplifier (op-amp) having a single-ended output terminal, a non-inverting input, and an inverting input, is operatively coupled to one of the anode or the cathode of the sensor by the inverting input. A feedback resistor having a resistance of at least approximately one giga-ohm (1 GΩ) is operatively coupled between the single-ended output terminal and the inverting input of the op-amp. A grounded field shunt is positioned adjacent to the feedback resistor. The op-amp, grounded field shunt, and feedback resistor are disposed within an electrical shield enclosure. The single-ended output terminal of the op-amp terminates outside of the electrical shield enclosure.
Another aspect of the present technology relates to a method of measuring a feature of a signal using the device. The signal to be measured is received by the sensor. An amplified signal based on the received signal is output at the single-ended output terminal of the op-amp. At least one feature of the signal is measured based on the amplified signal.
The high sensitivity photodetector with high-gain transimpedance amplifier of the present technology comprises a circuit topology for a simple, inexpensive, but highly sensitive photodetector with a high-gain transimpedance amplifier that can be used to detect and amplify faint optical signals such as the fluorescent signal emitted by voltage-sensitive fluorescent dyes in cardiac cells. The topology is a novel combination of existing circuit elements and shielding which enables the very low current generated by photons hitting the photodetector to be amplified and converted to a useable voltage that can be provided as an input for various measurements.
The present technology relates to a high sensitivity sensor. More specifically, the present technology relates to a high sensitivity photodetector with a high-gain transimpedance amplifier.
One aspect of the present technology relates to a device. The device includes a sensor having an anode and a cathode. An operational amplifier (op-amp) having a single-ended output terminal, a non-inverting input, and an inverting input, is operatively coupled to one of the anode or the cathode of the sensor by the inverting input. A feedback resistor having a resistance of at least approximately one gigaohm (1 GΩ) is operatively coupled between the single-ended output terminal and the inverting input of the op-amp. A grounded field shunt is positioned adjacent to the feedback resistor. The op-amp, grounded field shunt, and feedback resistor are disposed within an electrical shield enclosure. The single-ended output terminal of the op-amp terminates outside of the electrical shield enclosure.
Referring to
By way of example only, sensor 12 can be a MEMS (microelectromechanical system) microphone for measuring sound, a pressure transducer for measuring pressure, or a humidity sensor for measuring humidity. Preferably, sensor 12 has a low capacitance and does not require a high-frequency input for operation. Sensor 12 is electrically coupled to the differential input of op-amp 16 to provide electrical signals from the sensor 12 to op-amp 16 for amplification. Sensor 12 includes an anode 26 and cathode 28, which are coupled to op-amp 16 as described below.
In various embodiments, the sensor 12, such as a PIN photodiode, has a shunt resistance (rsh) that is greater than or equal to about 1, 3, 5, 10, 20, 30, 50, 75, 100, 150, 200, or 250 GΩ, and operates in a photovoltaic mode. In one particular embodiment, sensor 12 has a shunt resistance estimated to be about 35.5 GΩ. For a given low-pass cut-off frequency fL and photocurrent ip, the maximum signal to noise ratio (SNR) for device 10, such as a photodector, of the present technology are achieved using sensor 12, such as a PIN photodiode, with high shunt resistance (rsh) and op-amp 16 with low current and voltage noise, as described in further detail below.
In this embodiment, sensor 12 is located, at least partially, within first electrical shield 14, although in other embodiments sensor 12 does not have a separate electrical shield. First electric shield 14 is a roughly continuous layer of electrically conductive material. First electric shield 14 electrically shields sensor 12 from op-amp 16, feedback resistor 18, and optional capacitive T-network 20. In various embodiments, first electrical shield 24 is composed of a conductive metal, such as, but not limited to, copper. The first electrical shield 14 should be sufficient to prevent most (at least about 75%, 90%, 95%, 98%, 99%, 99.9% or 99.99%) or all parasitic capacitance, capacitive coupling, and crosstalk between sensor 12 and the other elements of device 10, as well as other adjacent circuits and devices. In an embodiment, first electrical shield 14 is connected to the ground plane as described in further detail below. In one embodiment, light is delivered to sensor 12, which is a PIN photodiode, via an optical fiber that collects the light to be measured. In this embodiment, the optical fiber passes through an opening in first electrical shield 14 to provide the light to be measured to sensor 12. In various embodiments, the first electrical shield 14 has an opening permitting light, or other measurand, to pass through to sensor 12, such as to a photosensitive surface of a photodiode.
In this embodiment, op-amp 16 is an OPA 140 op-amp. Op-amp 16 includes inverting input 30, non-inverting input 32, and single ended output terminal 34. Inverting input 30 of op-amp 16 can be connected to either anode 26 or cathode 28 of sensor 12. When anode 26 is connected to inverting input 30, non-inverting input 34 and cathode 28 are connected to ground in order to bias sensor 12, which in one embodiment is a PIN photodiode, into photovoltaic mode. When cathode 28 is connected to inverting input 30, non-inverting input 34 and anode 26 are connected to ground in order to bias sensor 12 into photovoltaic mode. In various embodiments, the current noise of op-amp 16 is less than or equal to about 2, 1.5, 1, 0.8, or 0.5 fA/√Hz, and the voltage noise of op-amp 16 is less than or equal to about 30, 20, 15, 10, 8, 7, 6, 5.5, or 5 nV/√Hz. In an embodiment, output terminal 34 of op-amp 16 is connected to a filter.
Feedback resistor 18 is connected in parallel to op-amp 16 (between inverting input 30 and output terminal 34 of op-amp 16). Feedback resistor 18 provides a very high resistance. In one embodiment, feedback resistor 18 provides a resistance greater than about 1 GΩ. In other embodiments, feedback resistor 18 has a resistance RF greater than or equal to about 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 40, 50, 60, 75, or 100 GΩ. In one particular embodiment, feedback resistor 18 is a 10 GΩ±5% feedback resistor in a 1206 package.
Grounded field shunt 20 is coupled to feedback resistor 18. Grounded field shunt 20 is positioned adjacent to feedback resistor 18, in a position slightly offset toward the output end of feedback resistor 18. Positioning the field shunt 20 closer to the output end of the feedback resistor 18 shifts any additional stray capacitance to output terminal 34 rather than inverting input 30
Optional capacitive T-network 22 is connected in parallel to op-amp 16 (between inverting input 30 and output terminal 34 of op-amp 16). Optional capacitive T-network 22 is also connected in parallel with feedback resistor 18 to enable bandwidth tuning. Optional capacitive T-network 22 enables bandwidth tuning and helps ensure that device 10 has the desired properties, as described in further detail below. In an embodiment, capacitive T-network 22 produces a capacitance from 1 fF to 50 fF. The values of CX were chosen at 600 fF and the trimmer cap has a range 10 p-180 pF to add 2-32 fF of capacitance for tuning the device's bandwidth, as described in further detail below.
Sensor 12, op-amp 16, feedback resistor 18, grounded field shunt 20, and optional capacitive T-network 22 are located within second electrical shield enclosure 24, such that each element is electrically shielded from any adjacent circuits and devices, including any second state signal conditioning circuits, such as second stage circuit 36 as shown in
Referring again to
Second electrical shield enclosure 24 is configured such that output terminal 34 of op-amp 16 terminates beyond second electrical shield enclosure 24. In one embodiment, second electrical shield 24 is connected to ground as described in further detail below. The connection of second electrical shield 24 to ground allows all or most of the stray capacitance to go from the circuit elements of device 10 to ground instead of from one circuit element to another circuit element. In an embodiment, second electrical shield 24 serves as a field shunt for feedback resistor 18 and there is no separate grounded field shunt 20. Although second electrical shield enclosure 24 is described, it is to be understood that in other embodiments, each of the elements in device 10 may be separate shielded from one another.
Referring now to
With a sufficiently high RF, such as an RF of about 10 giga-ohms, the SNR of device shown in
Device 10 of the present technology may be utilized to detect and amplify various parameters in operation, such as temperature, force, pressure, and acceleration, by way of example. In one particular embodiment, device 10 is a photodetector configured to detect and amplify optical signals. By way of example only, device 10 may be employed to detect and amplify faint optical signals, such as the fluorescent signal emitted by voltage-sensitive fluorescent dyes in cardiac cells.
Using a realistic ionic model of cardiac action potential and Ca2+ transients, for the majority of applications of optical mapping, the bandwidth can be reduced to as low as 250-300 Hz and often to 100 Hz. Eliminating excess bandwidth lowers the noise level and allows further increase of the gain of the TIA of device 10, thereby boosting the sensitivity of fluorescence recordings. In embodiments, the preceding SNRs of device 10 are achieved when the circuit has a bandwidth of about 50 Hz, 100 Hz, or about 200 Hz, or about 300 Hz.
Using the model, an expression for signal to noise ration (SNR) was created:
Here ξs is the current noise density of the op-amp, rsh is shunt resistance of the photodiode, k is Boltzmann's constant, T is the ambient temperature, q is the fundamental charge, cin is the input capacitance, and
The analysis of the SNR equation shows that as approaches infinity the SNR reaches its asymptotic value:
While SNR∞ represents the theoretical ceiling, a “practical target for feedback resistance RF can be RF,90, the feedback resistance corresponding to 90% of SNR∞. Increasing RF beyond RF,90 would no longer result in significant improvement of SNR.
The value of RF,90 can be approximated using the following simple formula:
For the examples shown in
Equation (5) is not only useful for assessing the practical limit for increasing RF, it can also be used for the selection of optimal circuit elements. For example by looking at the expression for given by equation (2) one can immediately see the rationale for using photodiodes with the highest shunt resistance (rsh). However, as shown below, equation (5) becomes particularly handy for the optimal selection of the op-amp, which as will be shown is more complicated than choosing the op-amp with the lowest ξs, ψT, and ψ1/f.
The analysis of equations (3) and (5) suggests that at small cin (cin<1 pF) the contribution of the voltage noise is relatively small and can be ignored. cj of the photodiode is the major contributor to, which is generally small for small photodetectors. For this range the best op-amp for the photodetector of the present technology should be an electrometer amplifier, which are known for their lowest current noise density, ξs˜0.1 fA/√{square root over (Hz)}.
However, this is not the case when such op-amps are used with photodiodes having moderate to large surface area and correspondingly large input junctional capacitance cj. Electrometer amplifiers usually have higher thermal and flicker noise voltages. This becomes a problem at small cf and large cin when the already high flicker and thermal noise voltages are amplified by the noise-gain-peaking mechanism to become significant.
The analysis shows, however, that unlike electrometer op-amps, op-amps #8, 10-12, and 14-18, are much less sensitive to photodiode capacitance. Accordingly, most of the op-amps selected for testing were from this group. These include the OPA140 (#14, star). Other op-amps that have been tested were the LMC6035 (#4) and the AD8641/AD8643 (#9), which have lower current noise than the OPA140 even though they experience a significant decrease in SNR∞ with large cj, they still have good performance with small photodiodes.
Current noise for specific op-amps is often specified in the data sheets provided by their manufacturer. Voltage noise is generally dominated by thermal noise (ψT) and flicker noise numerator (FNN), which are often specified in op-amp data sheets, and for the purposes of the present technology, the contribution of ψT and FNN to voltage noise can be roughly estimated by the equation √[ψT2+FNN2/fL]. The contribution of voltage noise is (2*pi*cin){circumflex over ( )}2*gamma*fL, and gamma can be estimated as ψT2*fL=FNN2.
Since the input capacitance cin from the PIN photodiode amplifies the op-amp's voltage noise (by cin2), the levels of ψT and/or FNN can be somewhat higher if cin is low. In large photodiodes, the main contributor to cin is the photodiode's junctional capacitance cj, which increases with the surface area of the photodiode. Smaller PIN photodiodes will generally have a smaller cj and will therefore tend to generate a lower cin.
In darkness, the shot noise term is removed from α and the equation is reduced to
αd=ξs2+4kT/rsh+(2πcin)2fLγ
Input referred noise in the absence of illumination is defined as
The absolute minimum value that RF can be is found by taking the limit of equation (7) as αd goes to zero.
Rearranging the above expression to solve for RF yields the minimum acceptable value of RF
For this equation, a bandwidth and maximum acceptable level of input referred noise are chosen to determine
This provides the requirement that:
RF≥1.95 GΩ, if fL=300 Hz and ind≤50 fArms
The range of αd that will meet the specification of ind≤50 fArms is determined by finding the lower limit of equation (7), where RF goes to zero.
If ind= the maximum value of αd can be determined:
Plugging in the values for and fL, yields =8.33×10−30 A2/Hz, or roughly 9.6 times the value of αd for the amplifier. Therefore the amplifier and photodiode parameters must be chosen such that:
αd≤8.33×10−30 A2/Hz, for ind≤50 fArms and fL=300 Hz
Equation (7) is plotted for discrete values αd of while sweeping RF. The results are shown in
In
αdξS2+ξrsh2+(2πcin)2γfL (11)
ξS2+ξrsh2=αd−(2πcin)2γfL (12)
The sum of ξS2 and ξrsh2 can be redefined as:
ξΣ2=ξS2+ξrsh2 (13)
Substituting the above equation into equation (12) and using the worst-case value of αd yields:
ξΣ2=−(2πcin)2γfL (14)
The above equation illustrates that neither ξΣ2 or (2πcin)2l γfL may be larger than . It can therefore be concluded that:
ξΣ2≤8.33×10−30 A2/Hz and (2πcin)2γfL≤8.33×10−30 A2/Hz and (14) is true.
Substituting equation (15) into equation (13) and solving for rsh yields:
Where ξΣ2() is ξΣ2 for αd= Using the worst-case value of ξΣ2=8.33×10−30 A2/Hz, it is determined that
rsh≥1.95 GΩ, for ξΣ2>>ξS2
and
ξS2<ξΣ2 or ξS<2.88 fA/√{square root over (Hz)}
Considering the worst-case curve from
The term (2πcin)2fLγ is defined as shown below:
ξγ=(2πcin)2fLγ (17)
Rearranging the above equation to solve for yields
To generate
Rearranging equation (3) and solving for ψT provides:
In
Because it is difficult to determine exactly what the resulting bandwidth will be from the components chosen for the high-sensitivity photodetector with high-gain transimpedance amplifier (PD-TIA) of the present technology, an optional capacitive T-network is added for tuning the bandwidth with 2-32 fF of capacitance. In embodiments, the PD-TIA has a bandwidth of about 50 Hz, 100 Hz, 150 Hz, 200 Hz, 300 Hz, 400 Hz, 500 Hz, or 650 Hz.
In recognition that the performance stats and parameters given in the spec sheets for electronic components are often approximations, the term ‘about’ is used in the preceding to mean that the actual value is within a certain range of that specified, such as within about ±1%, ±2%, ±3%, ±5%, ±10%, ±15% or ±25% of the value specified.
Although preferred embodiments have been depicted and described in detail herein, it will be apparent to those skilled in the relevant art that various modifications, additions, substitutions, and the like can be made without departing from the spirit of the technology and these are therefore considered to be within the scope of the technology as defined in the claims which follow.
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application Ser. No. 62/744,883, filed Oct. 12, 2018, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
7304536 | Sutardja | Dec 2007 | B1 |
10277180 | Werking | Apr 2019 | B2 |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20200116563 A1 | Apr 2020 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
62744883 | Oct 2018 | US |