The present invention relates to the thermal management of integrated circuits. In particular, the present invention relates to an integrated circuit stack comprising a plurality of integrated circuit layers comprising at least a first circuit layer electrically connected to a second circuit layer and at least one cooling layer arranged in a space between the first and second circuit layer.
The cooling of integrated circuits, of which increased performance expectations are placed, i.e. high-performance integrated circuits, is a particular challenge in a time of ever increasing circuit integration and performance demands. With increased computing requirements, so too do the processing speeds of integrated circuits and thus their clock frequencies increase, which leads to increased power consumption and, thus, heat dissipation. By a reduction in the size of individual components, such as transistors and memory cells, these components become faster. For electrical on-chip interconnects the opposite is the case. Due to the scaling effect the RC-time constant increases, which results in an increased signal flight time. This effect limits the chip performance and is called reverse scaling.
In known integrated circuits, most circuit components are arranged in what is essentially a single plane of a semiconductor material, often referred to as a die. Such a configuration allows increased efficiency in the cooling of the integrated circuit by means of a cooling arrangement mounted on the back surface of the integrated circuit. However, for the reduced length of signaling paths between individual circuit components, which translates in reduced signal flight times, and, also, to further aid chip integration, integrated circuit stacks are being developed, comprising multiple circuit layers stacked on top of each other. Cooling of such devices from the back side is particularly challenging as the dissipated heat flux of all the components accumulates and the conductive thermal resistance is increased with each additional component or circuit layer. This results in a higher temperature gradient in the chip stack.
An alternative cooling approach is the interlayer thermal management of such vertically integrated chip stacks. Such an approach is described in “Direct Liquid Cooling of a Stacked Multichip Module” by X. Y. Chen, K. C. Toh, and J. C. Chai. Therein, direct single-phase liquid cooling of a stacked multichip module is examined. A further integrated circuit stack is described in a paper titled “Integrated Microchannel Cooling for Three-Dimensional Electronic Circuit Architectures” by J.-M. Koo, S. Im, L. Yang and K. E. Goodson. This paper studies three-dimensional circuit cooling by means of an integrated microchannel network. A further integrated circuit stack with interlayer cooling is known from a paper titled to “Process Integration of 3D Chip Stack with Vertical Interconnection” by K. Takahashi, Y. Taguchi, M. Tomisaka et al.
So far arrangements for cooling integrated circuit stacks with interlayer cooling are either concerned with the cooling of relatively low-performance integrated circuits, in particular memory modules, having a uniform structure and heat-dissipation or stacks with just peripheral electrical interconnects for lower bandwidth applications.
It remains a challenge to provide integrated circuit stacks for other kinds of applications, such as high-performance processors. It is a further challenge to provide a method for configuring integrated circuit stacks for higher-power operation and more efficient cooling. It is a further challenge to provide an integrated circuit stack and a method for its thermal management, which is applicable to smaller channel geometries, for example, of less than 300 μm gap between individual circuit layers.
According to an embodiment of one aspect of the invention, an integrated circuit stack is provided. The integrated circuit stack comprises a plurality of integrated circuit layers comprising at least a first circuit layer electrically connected to a second circuit layer, the first circuit layer having at least one first area of higher heat generation and at least one second area of lower heat generation, and at least one cooling layer arranged in a space between the first and second circuit layer, the cooling layer comprising at least one fluid inlet, at least one fluid outlet and a hollow space hydraulically connecting the fluid inlet and the fluid outlet for cooling at least the first circuit layer using a cooling fluid. The at least one cooling layer comprises a means for creating a non-uniform flow pattern for the cooling fluid in the hollow space resulting in a higher heat transfer in the first area than in the second area of the first circuit layer.
By providing a means for creating a non-uniform flow pattern in a cooling layer arranged between a first and a second circuit layer of an integrated circuit stack, the heat transfer capability provided by a cooling fluid is adapted according to cooling requirements of the first and second area of the first circuit layer.
According to an embodiment of the first aspect, the at least one cooling layer comprises at least one guide element directing at least part of the cooling fluid towards the first area. By providing at least one guide element, which directs at least part of the cooling fluid towards the first area, a cooling effect in a first area having a higher heat generation is further improved.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the at least one guide element is adapted for creating at least one first flow passing the first area having a higher mass flow rate than a second flow passing the second area. By creating a first and second flow having a higher and lower mass flow rate, respectively, the cooling performance in the first area is enhanced with respect to the second area.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the at least one guide element comprises a funnel structure having a first larger opening towards the fluid inlet and a second smaller opening towards the first area. By integrating a funnel structure into the at least one cooling layer, a flow of cooling fluid is condensed in the first area resulting in an improved cooling of the first area.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the at least one cooling layer comprises a channel structure having a first width in the first area and a second width in the second area, the first width being smaller than the second width. By providing a channel structure having different widths in the first and second area, the velocity of the cooling fluid is adapted to their different cooling requirements.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the width of the channel structure is reduced along at least one path from the fluid inlet to the fluid outlet. By providing a channel structure, whose width is reduced along a path of the cooling fluid, the velocity of the cooling fluid is adapted to the decreasing cooling capacity of the cooling fluid along the path.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the at least one cooling layer comprises a grid structure having a lower density in the first area than in the second area. By increasing the density of the grid structure in the second area with respect to the first area, the flow to resistance in the second area is increased, resulting in an increased flow of cooling fluid through the first area.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the at least one cooling layer comprises a grid structure having grid elements, at least one first grid element arranged in the first area having a larger cross-section than a second grid-element arranged in the second area. By changing the cross-section of grid elements arranged in the first and second area, the heat transfer in the first and second area is adapted to their respective cooling requirements.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the grid structure comprises electrical connections between the first and second circuit layer. By using electrical connections between the first and second circuit layer in order to form a grid structure, both the electrical connectivity between the different circuit layers and an adaptation of the flow of the cooling fluid through the cooling layer is achieved.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the at least one cooling layer comprises a first surface at the first circuit layer and a second surface at the second circuit layer, the first and second surface having a smaller distance between each other in the first area than in the second area. By reducing the distance between the first and second surface of the at least one cooling layer in the first area, a flow of cooling fluid is accelerated in the first area, resulting in an improved cooling performance.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the distance between the first and second surface is reduced along at least one path from the fluid inlet to the fluid outlet. By reducing the distance between the first and second surface, the velocity of the flow along the at least one path is accelerated toward the fluid outlet, equaling the heat transfer capability along the path caused by the heating up of the cooling fluid.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the fluid inlet is placed closer to the first area than to the second area. By placing the first area, having a higher heat generation, closer to the fluid inlet than the second area, cooling in the first area is increased due to the comparably lower temperature of the cooling fluid at the fluid inlet than at/closer to the fluid outlet.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the fluid outlet is placed closer to the second area than to the first area. By placing the second area, having a lower heat generation, closer to the fluid outlet, cooling in the second area is reduced as the cooling fluid has already heated up on its way from the fluid inlet to the second area.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the fluid inlet and fluid outlet are arranged in proximity to a common corner of the cooling layer and the first area is arranged closer to the common corner than the second area. By arranging the first area in proximity of a corner common to a fluid inlet and a fluid outlet, the first area of higher heat generation is placed in a direct connection between the fluid inlet and the fluid outlet resulting in an increased mass flow rate of cooling fluid towards the common corner.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the cooling layer comprises at least two fluid inlets or at least two fluid outlets, such that a first flow from the first inlet to the first outlet passing the first area is shorter than a second flow from the second fluid inlet to the first fluid outlet or from the first fluid inlet to the second fluid outlet, respectively. By placing the first area in a first flow having a reduced length with respect to a second flow, cooling of the first area is enhanced with respect to the second area.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the cooling layer has a rectangular shape, having four sides, the first and the third side being parallel to each other, and the second and the fourth side being parallel to each other, the first and the third side being orthogonal to the second and the fourth side. The cooling layer comprises two fluid inlets and two fluid outlets arranged on the fourth sides. By using a four-port cooling fluid supply, the mass flow rate of the cooling fluid in the cooling layer can be further improved resulting in better heat dissipation for high-performance integrated circuits.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the two fluid inlets are arranged on the first and the third side and two fluid outlets are arranged on the second and the fourth side. By providing the fluid inlets and fluid outlets on opposite sides of the cooling layer, a faster flow of cooling fluid is created at four corners, increasing the cooling performance there.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the two fluid inlets are arranged on the first and the second side and two fluid outlets are arranged on the third and the fourth side. By providing the fluid inlets and fluid outlets on opposite sides of the cooling layer, a faster flow of cooling fluid is created at two corners, while preserving a constant flow in a central area of the cooling layer.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the integrated circuit stack comprising at least a first and a second cooling layers arranged above and below at least one common circuit layer, wherein a flow of the cooling fluid in the first cooling layer is directed in a first direction and a flow of the cooling fluid in the second cooling layer is directed in a second direction, being different from the first direction. By directing a first and a second flow of cooling fluid in a first and a second cooling layer in different directions, the overall cooling of an intermediate circuit layer is adapted to its cooling requirements.
According to a further embodiment of the first aspect, the integrated circuit stack comprising at least a plurality of cooling layers, wherein a flow of the cooling fluid in alternating cooling layers is directed in opposite directions. By directing flows of cooling fluid in alternating cooling layers in opposite directions, the overall cooling performance is equalized.
According to an embodiment of a second aspect of the present invention, a method for configuring an integrated circuit stack comprising at least a first and a second circuit layer, the first and the second circuit layer being electrically connected to one another, at least the first circuit layer having a non-uniform power distribution and a hollow cooling layer arranged between the first and second circuit layer is provided. The method comprises the steps: 29 computing a junction temperature of a first and a second area of the first circuit layer for a given flow of a cooling fluid through the hollow cooling layer in a given configuration, and step 30 modifying the configuration of the cooling layer or the first circuit layer to reduce a difference in the computed junction temperature of the first and the second area of the first circuit layer.
By reducing a difference in the computed junction temperature of a first and second area of a first circuit layer, the thermal design of the integrated circuit stack is improved.
According to a further embodiment of the second aspect, the step of modifying the configuration comprises adding, removing or changing at least one guide element or surface feature of the cooling layer or the circuit layer in such a way that the mass flow rate in the first area having an above average junction temperature is increased or the mass flow rate in the second area having a below average junction temperature is reduced, or both. By modifying a guide element or surface feature of the cooling layer or circuit layer in order to increase or decrease the mass flow rate of the cooling fluid or the convective thermal resistance of the first and second area, respectively, the thermal design of the integrated circuit stack is improved.
According to a further embodiment of the second aspect, the steps of computing and modifying are repeated until a uniform junction temperature is computed for the first and second area of the circuit layer. By repeating the above steps until a uniform junction temperature is computed for both areas of the first circuit layer, the temperature of different circuit areas can be balanced.
According to a further embodiment of the second aspect, the steps of computing and modifying are repeated until a uniform junction temperature is computed for the entire surface of the circuit layer. By repeating the steps of computing and modifying until a uniform junction temperature is computed for the entire surface, the heat dissipation can be optimized for the entire circuit layer of the integrated circuit stack, achieving an optimal configuration for the integrated circuit stack.
The invention and its embodiments will be more fully appreciated by reference to the following detailed description of presently preferred but nonetheless illustrative embodiments in accordance with the present invention when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
The figures are illustrating:
In the drawings, common reference signs are used to refer to like elements in different embodiments. In addition, added postfixes in the form of characters are used to distinguish individual elements of a group of similar elements. In cases where no such distinction is made in the corresponding description, any element of that group may be referred to.
Each of the cooling layers 3 provides a hollow space between adjoining circuit layers 2 and has a fluid inlet 4 and a fluid outlet 5. In the example presented in
For electrically connecting different integrated circuit layers 2 with one another, vertical electrical connections 6 which can be arranged in a true area array are passed through the cooling layers 3. Further electrical connections 6 are provided between the circuit layer 2a and a contact surface 7 arranged on a substrate 8. The contact surface 7 and the substrate 8 are used for providing electrical connections for the integrated circuit stack 1 to a printed circuit board, for example. For this purpose, the substrate 8 comprises for example multiple solder balls acting as contact pads 9, to connect the integrated circuit stack 1 with a ball grid array (BGA) of a carrier or substrate. Alternatively, the integrated circuit stack 1 may also be soldered directly onto a printed circuit board (PCB) or connected directly or indirectly by any other known or future bounding technology.
The thermal management of a three-dimensional integrated circuit stack 1 as shown in
In integrated circuit stacks 1 with an increased density of electrical connections 6, a flow rate of a cooling fluid 10 pumped through the cooling layers 3 is limited due to the increased flow resistance of the geometry of the integrated circuit stack 1. The result is a reduced mass flow rate for a given pressure drop from the fluid inlet 4 to the fluid outlet 5. In consequence, the main temperature lift of the semiconductor junctions embedded in the circuit layers 2 is caused by the increased temperature of the cooling fluid 10 which picks up the dissipated power, also referred to as “sensible heat” in the following.
Various contributions to the junction temperature TJ of a circuit layer 2 having a uniform heat to dissipation are represented in
As can be seen in
The problem of cooling different areas of a circuit layer 2 is particular complicated, if the heat distribution of an integrated circuit layer 2 is non-uniform. This is particularly the case for high-performance processing devices, which comprise a relatively small processor core, for example for performing arithmetic operations, and a relatively large cache memory, which dissipates far less heat than the processor core. If a processor core would be arranged in the right-hand part of a circuit layer 2 according to
In the embodiment shown in
According to the presented embodiment, the electrical connections 6 may be realized with through wafer vias. The heat transfer geometry is structured into the silicon and can comprise a pin fin array. The circuit layers 2 may be bonded with an electrical conductive solder material, which forms an island, surrounded by a ring structure which seals the electrical interconnect from the cooling fluid 10. Both bonding areas conduct heat to the fins. The integrated circuit stack 1 is then packaged into a thermal expansion matched housing 26 such as silicon comprising a cooling fluid manifold and the contact pads 9 with the possibility of ball grid array bonding. This packaging approach reduces stress induced to the fragile circuit layers 2 from thermal expansion mismatch, allows two sided heat removal for all circuit layers 2 and a so-called four-port manifolding scheme described later.
In consequence, the cooling fluid 10 flows through the cooling layers 3a to 3d in alternating directions above and below each circuit layer 2a to 2c. Because the circuit layers 2a to 2c are each arranged between two adjoining cooling layers 3a to 3d with alternating directions of flow, each circuit layer 2a to 2c is cooled from both the left-hand and the right-hand side. Considering the junction temperature TJ and the cooling performance, as indicated in
The conventional arrangement shown in
Consequently the convective resistance has to be reduced at the cost of increased pumping power to keep the junction temperature below Tmax.
As seen above, a more uniform junction temperature TJ close to the maximal junction temperature Tmax at the maximal chip load result in a more efficient cooling arrangement for a given power map. If, either the power map of the circuit layer 1 is designed according to the cooling layer's 3 local heat removal capability or the cooling layer 3 is designed for a given power map of a circuit layer 2, the overall cooling efficiency of the circuit stack 1 is improved. In both cases the heat removal design should consider the implementation density of electrical connections 6 in the given area.
A desirable configuration from an electrical and thermal prospective may be obtained by adjusting the power map of the circuit layer 2 as much as possible towards the thermal needs and to design the cooling layer 3 according to the power map. The result is a reduced pumping power due to a lower flow rate and pressure drop across the cooling layer 3 and a maximal fluid temperature at the fluid outlet 5.
In server applications, where many processors have to be cooled in parallel, reduced flow rate per die allows much smaller diameter tubing and therefore more compact cooling fluid interconnects in the server rack with a reduction in pumping power. The increased fluid outlet temperature causes a reduced secondary heat exchanger volume and weight due to the increased heat flux caused by the improved temperature difference of the two fluid loops or in best case eliminates the secondary cooling loop by direct exchange of the heat to the environment.
In view of these considerations,
In addition, an additional surface feature 23 is arranged on the top surface 21 in the first area 11. The surface feature 23 narrows the distance between the top surface 21 and the circuit layer 2 in the first area 11 of the hot spot 22. For the reason set out above, the flow rate of the cooling fluid 10 is increased in the first area 11 resulting in an improved cooling of the hot spot 22.
The described variable gap cooling scheme stands symbolically for other possible implementation schemes of a variable convective heat transfer cooling structure, such as variable width channels, shown in
In the embodiment shown in
Calculations underlying
For increased cooling efficiency of the arrangement shown in
In particular, in a first area 11, the heat dissipation of the circuit layer 2 is greatest. In subsequent second areas 12a to 12e, the heat dissipation decreases. Consequently, parts of the circuit layer 2 having particularly high heat dissipation are arranged closer to the fluid inlet 4, while parts of the circuit layer 2 having a lower heat dissipation are arranged closer to the fluid outlet 5. As a result, the junction temperature TJ of the circuit layer 2 remains constant over the entire width of the circuit layer 2.
a to
The data provided in
More efficient heat removal at small gap widths can also be realized by a so-called four-port cooling layer architecture described below. In the two port configuration the fluid inlet 4 and fluid outlet 5 are situated at opposite locations of the cooling layer 3, whereas in the four-port case all for sides of the cooling layer 3 are used to deliver and drain coolant. Fluid inlets 4 can be opposite and separated by fluid outlets 5 as shown in
In the arrangement shown in
The twofold symmetric approach is capable of handling four hot spots 22, each located in a corner 24 of the circuit layer 2, whereas the single symmetric case is capable of handling two hot spots 22 in corners 24 arranged between fluid inlet 4 and fluid outlet 5. The twofold symmetry case has a stagnation zone in the center of the cooling layer 3 with a low heat removal rate, which can be reduced using guiding structures as described above in order to minimize this low performing zone, by a central heat conduction structure or by a layer dependent offset of the stagnation zone from the center.
Computational fluid dynamic results have been used to compute the velocity field and the circuit layer surface temperature for a given uniform power dissipation. A two-port cooling layer 3 has a uniform fluid velocity, whereas a four-port cooling layer 3 shows a strong increase in fluid velocity towards the corner 24 of the cooling layer 3 and also has higher velocities at the central area 25 of the cooling layer 3 caused by the shear stress from the high velocity fluid in the first areas 22a and 22b. By increasing the x- and y-size of the cooling layer 3 the flow rate of the two-port cold plate stays constant. This results in a reduced cooling performance for larger circuit layers 2 since the mass flow rate normalized per area is decreasing. On the other hand, the total flow rate of the four-port cooling layer 3 increases. It was found that the surface temperature of the four-port cooling layer 3 is on 90% of the area lower than the temperature of the two-port cooling layer 3.
In particular, the central area 25 will be cooled more or less equally despite the twofold symmetrical four-port configuration which was already described with reference to
The density of the grid structure is modulated in
In
In a step A, the junction temperature TJ of at least one circuit layer 2 is computed. Computation may be based on a known power map of the circuit layer 2 or its constituting parts. Alternatively, the junction temperature TJ may be obtained by measurements performed at a prototype of the circuit layer 2.
If the power map of the circuit layer 2 is known, its junction temperature TJ may be computed in a successive fashion, starting from a point with known boundary conditions, such as the temperature at the fluid inlet 4 and, subsequently computing the junction temperature TJ of adjoining areas, until the junction temperature TJ of the entire surface of the circuit layer 2 is known.
In a step B, one or more first area 11 may be identified. In one embodiment, at first an average junction temperature TJ may be computed. Then, the junction temperature TJ of different areas is compared with the average temperature or a given maximal junction temperature Tmax. If, for example, one or more areas having an above average temperature or one or more areas having a below average temperature are identified, these are marked as first areas 11 and second areas 12, respectively.
In a step C, a test is performed, testing whether the junction temperature TJ is sufficiently uniform. If this is the case, the optimization will end. For example the junction temperature TJ to may be constant over the entire surface of the circuit layer 2, i.e. the circuit stack 1 is in its optimal configuration with respect to efficient cooling. Alternatively, the optimization procedure may end, once the junction temperature TJ of the hottest first area 11 identified in step B lies below a maximal junction temperature Tmax, or once a predetermined number of optimization steps have been performed. The process may also end, if no further equalization was achieved in a previous modification of the integrated circuit stack design.
Otherwise, i.e. if the junction temperature TJ is not sufficiently uniform, the method proceeds in step D, by modifying a surface of either the cooling layer 3 or the circuit layer 2 in an attempt to improve the cooling performance of the circuit stack 1. In particular, means are employed in order to increase a mass flow rate in the first area 11 or to decrease the mass flow rate in the second area 12, or both. Such means may be chosen freely from those disclosed above or otherwise known to a person skilled in the art of circuit or cooling layer design.
In particular, one or several of the following methods may be employed: step 119. 1. Circuit components associated with the first area 11 may be moved closer to one or several fluid inlets 4, steop 120. 2. Additional fluid inlets 4 or fluid outlets 5 may be provided, step 121. 3. A gap width of a hollow space 20 may be reduced in the first area 11 or enlarged in a second area 12, step 122. A density of a grid may be reduced in the first area 11 or increased in the second area 12, e.g. by relocating electrical inter-circuit layer connections 6, step 123. Guide elements 19 directing at least part of a flow 13 toward the first area 11 may be provided or enlarged, step 124, 6. A channel 14 supplying or draining the first area 11 with an increased flow 13 of the cooling fluid 10 may be provided.
Subsequently, the method may be repeated starting at step A with computing an updated junction temperature T.
Although the various features for creating a non-uniform flow pattern have been described with reference to different embodiments above, it will be obvious to a person skilled in the art, that any of these features may be arranged and combined in many other configurations in order to improve the cooling efficiency of an integrated circuit stack 1.
Number | Date | Country | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
PCT/IB2008/53768 | Sep 2008 | WO | international |
This application is a divisional of and claims priority from U.S. patent application Ser. No. 12/678,298 filed on Mar. 16, 2010, now U.S. Pat. No. 8,363,402, which is based on International Application No. PCT/IB08/53768, filed on Sep. 17, 2008 which claims priority to 07116581,5 filed on Sep. 17, 2007, the entire disclosure of each of the above applications is hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety.
Number | Name | Date | Kind |
---|---|---|---|
3616533 | Heap et al. | Nov 1971 | A |
4704658 | Yokouchi et al. | Nov 1987 | A |
4765397 | Chrysler et al. | Aug 1988 | A |
4995892 | Garrett et al. | Feb 1991 | A |
5006924 | Frankeny et al. | Apr 1991 | A |
5014161 | Lee et al. | May 1991 | A |
5168919 | Berenholz et al. | Dec 1992 | A |
5305184 | Andresen et al. | Apr 1994 | A |
5323292 | Brzezinski | Jun 1994 | A |
5343360 | Sanwo | Aug 1994 | A |
5448108 | Quon et al. | Sep 1995 | A |
5485671 | Larson et al. | Jan 1996 | A |
5495490 | Rice et al. | Feb 1996 | A |
5720338 | Larson et al. | Feb 1998 | A |
5763950 | Fujisaki et al. | Jun 1998 | A |
5774334 | Kawamura et al. | Jun 1998 | A |
5978220 | Frey et al. | Nov 1999 | A |
6052284 | Suga et al. | Apr 2000 | A |
6253835 | Chu et al. | Jul 2001 | B1 |
6351384 | Daikoku et al. | Feb 2002 | B1 |
6717812 | Pinjala | Apr 2004 | B1 |
6724792 | Rice | Apr 2004 | B2 |
6744136 | Dubhashi | Jun 2004 | B2 |
7030317 | Oman | Apr 2006 | B1 |
7077189 | Reyzin et al. | Jul 2006 | B1 |
7133286 | Schmidt et al. | Nov 2006 | B2 |
7205653 | Brandenburg et al. | Apr 2007 | B2 |
7365981 | Myers et al. | Apr 2008 | B2 |
7411290 | Lee et al. | Aug 2008 | B2 |
7551439 | Peugh et al. | Jun 2009 | B2 |
7608924 | Myers et al. | Oct 2009 | B2 |
7660335 | Thiagarajan et al. | Feb 2010 | B2 |
7768777 | Miller | Aug 2010 | B2 |
7990711 | Andry et al. | Aug 2011 | B1 |
8014150 | Campbell et al. | Sep 2011 | B2 |
8094454 | Lowry | Jan 2012 | B2 |
8363402 | Brunschwiler et al. | Jan 2013 | B2 |
20010033477 | Inoue et al. | Oct 2001 | A1 |
20020162673 | Cook et al. | Nov 2002 | A1 |
20030053294 | Yamada et al. | Mar 2003 | A1 |
20030080413 | Dubhashi | May 2003 | A1 |
20040251530 | Yamaji | Dec 2004 | A1 |
20050128702 | Mongia et al. | Jun 2005 | A1 |
20050269665 | Wylie | Dec 2005 | A1 |
20080179736 | Hartwell | Jul 2008 | A1 |
20080272485 | Myers et al. | Nov 2008 | A1 |
20100208427 | Horiuchi et al. | Aug 2010 | A1 |
Number | Date | Country |
---|---|---|
1662852 | May 2006 | EP |
03139899 | Jun 1991 | JP |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
20120331433 A1 | Dec 2012 | US |
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 12678298 | US | |
Child | 13568720 | US |