The disclosed embodiments of the invention relate generally to multi-chip packages, and relate more particularly to interconnect structures in such packages.
A continuing focus of the microelectronics industry is the enablement of computer chips (also referred to as dies) having greater density, higher performance, and lower cost. As part of this effort, microelectronic packages containing multiple dies have been developed. Such multi-chip packages (MCPs) offer the potential for increased architectural flexibility at reduced cost but to do so must provide appropriate die-to-die interconnect densities in a way that is cost-effective. The interconnect density is an important consideration because an insufficient number of die connections would limit the bandwidth capability for the affected die interface, and thus logic-logic and/or logic-memory communications would suffer.
The disclosed embodiments will be better understood from a reading of the following detailed description, taken in conjunction with the accompanying figures in the drawings in which:
For simplicity and clarity of illustration, the drawing figures illustrate the general manner of construction, and descriptions and details of well-known features and techniques may be omitted to avoid unnecessarily obscuring the discussion of the described embodiments of the invention. Additionally, elements in the drawing figures are not necessarily drawn to scale. For example, the dimensions of some of the elements in the figures may be exaggerated relative to other elements to help improve understanding of embodiments of the present invention. The same reference numerals in different figures denote the same elements, while similar reference numerals may, but do not necessarily, denote similar elements.
The terms “first,” “second,” “third,” “fourth,” and the like in the description and in the claims, if any, are used for distinguishing between similar elements and not necessarily for describing a particular sequential or chronological order. It is to be understood that the terms so used are interchangeable under appropriate circumstances such that the embodiments of the invention described herein are, for example, capable of operation in sequences other than those illustrated or otherwise described herein. Similarly, if a method is described herein as comprising a series of steps, the order of such steps as presented herein is not necessarily the only order in which such steps may be performed, and certain of the stated steps may possibly be omitted and/or certain other steps not described herein may possibly be added to the method. Furthermore, the terms “comprise,” “include,” “have,” and any variations thereof, are intended to cover a non-exclusive inclusion, such that a process, method, article, or apparatus that comprises a list of elements is not necessarily limited to those elements, but may include other elements not expressly listed or inherent to such process, method, article, or apparatus.
The terms “left,” “right,” “front,” “back,” “top,” “bottom,” “over,” “under,” and the like in the description and in the claims, if any, are used for descriptive purposes and not necessarily for describing permanent relative positions. It is to be understood that the terms so used are interchangeable under appropriate circumstances such that the embodiments of the invention described herein are, for example, capable of operation in other orientations than those illustrated or otherwise described herein. The term “coupled,” as used herein, is defined as directly or indirectly connected in an electrical or non-electrical manner. Objects described herein as being “adjacent to” each other may be in physical contact with each other, in close proximity to each other, or in the same general region or area as each other, as appropriate for the context in which the phrase is used. Occurrences of the phrase “in one embodiment” herein do not necessarily all refer to the same embodiment.
In one embodiment of the invention, a multi-chip package comprises a substrate having a first side, an opposing second side, and a third side that extends from the first side to the second side, a first die attached to the first side of the substrate and a second die also attached to the first side of the substrate, and a bridge adjacent to the third side of the substrate and attached to the first die and to the second die. No portion of the substrate is underneath the bridge. The bridge creates a connection between the first die and the second die. Alternatively, the bridge may be disposed in a cavity in the substrate or between the substrate and a die layer. The bridge may constitute an active die and may be attached to the substrate using wirebonds.
Shrinking die sizes coupled with increasing die performance requirements dictate that the density of the corresponding die-to-die interconnects must be increased. As may be expected, several manufacturing issues must be addressed in order to accomplish this goal. One such issue is the difficulty inherent in fabricating interconnects within an organic substrate material. In order to overcome this problem, a silicon interposer sandwiched between the dies and the package substrate has been proposed. The use of a standard copper damascene process allows fabrication of lines and spaces of submicron dimensions. However, the large silicon interposer area and need for through-silicon vias (TSVs) make this approach an expensive one, thus negating the perceived MCP-derived cost benefits.
Embodiments of the invention enable density scaling of interconnect structures that represents an accelerated improvement over existing technology generations by making use of silicon bridges (or bridges made of other materials) that are embedded in or attached to the package substrate. These bridges need to support only the dense die-to-die interconnect from die edge to die edge and can consequently be much smaller than a silicon interposer. The silicon bridge concept also eliminates the need for TSV technology. In addition to greatly increased communication bandwidth due to high density interconnect structures, embodiments of the invention may also enable improved assembly processes due (at least in part) to the maturity of silicon process technology.
Certain embodiments of the invention may enable the fabrication of MCPs having unprecedented die-to-die interconnect densities that would in turn enable MCP-type cost savings, modularity, and architectural flexibility. Examples of such potential benefits include improved reticle and wafer utilization by die aspect ratio optimization, the ability to combine within a single package dies using different optimized silicon (or other) processes or dies incorporating differing or incompatible design methodologies, the potential to assemble non-rectangular or large “super-dies,” the ability to combine dies or die stacks with differing heights, and others.
Embodiments of the invention also enable the precise alignment of bridges, including silicon bridges, to a package substrate. Such alignment may be important in the creation of an overall well-defined bump field for subsequent die attach, especially in view of the high interconnect densities targeted on the silicon bridges. Furthermore, an on-die type density may allow reuse of existing circuit designs with minimal modification, and many available pins at the die-package interface may enable simple protocols and good input/output (I/O) power efficiency.
Some embodiments of the invention make use of a hybrid flip-chip/wirebond assembled active “satellite” die (or dies) where the die is flip-chip connected to at least one processing unit die and is also connected by wirebond directly to the package substrate. The processing unit die is assembled to the package substrate using flip-chip interconnects. The flip-chip interconnects between the satellite die and the processing unit die enable high-density, high-speed communication between the satellite die and the processing unit die and also (where multiple processing unit dies are involved) allow the satellite die to play the role of a high-speed silicon bridge enabling high-speed, high-density connectivity between two or more processing unit dies in addition to providing the active functionality of the satellite die to one or more of the processing unit dies. The wirebond connections to the satellite die allow for power delivery to that die and further allow additional I/O or control signal connectivity apart from that provided by the flip chip connections to the processing unit die(s). As with the embodiments described above, TSVs are avoided altogether.
Referring now to the drawings,
In certain embodiments, as mentioned above, bridge 140 comprises silicon. Silicon bridges are used because silicon process technology is relatively advanced, and interconnect pitches and line widths that are achievable using existing silicon process technology are significantly smaller than what is possible using, for example, currently available technology for copper lines in polymer layers. Thus die-to-die interconnects may be constructed with much greater density when silicon bridges are used than when such interconnects are fabricated within typical organic substrate materials. Speaking generally, embodiments of the invention employ silicon bridges with high density solder bumps and fine lines, with the latter being made using traditional silicon processes.
In some embodiments, bridge 140 can be a passive component, in that it has no functionality other than to provide a high-speed, high-density signaling pathway between dies 120 and 130. In other embodiments, bridge 140 comprises an active die, having its own functionality apart from a bridging function, that constitutes a third die (die 120 and die 130 being the first two) of multi-chip package 100. In such embodiments, bridge 140 could have a design enabled for hybrid assembly, such as having both bumps for flip-chip interconnects and pads for wirebond connections prepared on the same side (surface) of the active die. Furthermore, such embodiments could reduce manufacturing expenses. For example, a processing unit die requiring on-package external memory in addition to connectivity with another processing unit die could be served by a single bridge die having fast local memory functionality, thus eliminating the need for any additional components, as such a bridge would provide both functions.
As an example, the active die can be an active silicon die, or the active die can comprise other semiconducting materials such as gallium arsenide (GaAs), silicon germanium (SiGe), or any other suitable semiconducting material or combination of semiconducting materials. Although this description will from time to time make reference to an “active silicon die,” it should be understood that active dies of any suitable semiconducting material or combination of materials are also contemplated. It should also be understood that what are referred to herein as active dies, no matter what material or materials they are made of, have their own functionality apart from their ability to act as a bridge and provide connections between other dies.
In the illustrated embodiments, the intersection of side 111 and side 213 creates an edge 117. In
As illustrated, dies 120 and 130 are arranged such that they overhang an internal or an external edge of substrate 110: a portion 221 of die 120 overhangs edge 117 and, similarly, a portion 231 of die 130 overhangs edge 117. As suggested above, die overhang at an internal substrate edge implies substrate 110 has an aperture, such as aperture 119. In at least some embodiments this aperture is slightly larger than bridge 140. In cases where multiple bridges are desired multiple apertures may be provided, or smaller apertures can be combined into a larger aperture accommodating multiple bridges, depending on design requirements. Overhang at an external substrate edge implies that dies 120 and 130 are mounted near the package substrate periphery, as discussed above and as illustrated in
It may be seen in
For reasons discussed below, in some embodiments (such as, for example, where bridge 140 is an active silicon die), bridge 140 is attached to substrate 110 using wirebonds 241. (These wirebonds have been omitted from
As mentioned above, no TSVs are needed in bridge 140 or for the other bridges/satellite dies described herein. The satellite dies are connected to the processing unit dies using flip-chip (face-to-face) connections in order to allow for interfacing the processing unit and satellite die I/O and for providing an interface (where desired) for die-to-die bridge functionality. All or some of the other (slower) I/Os of the satellite die and its power and ground connects are, in certain embodiments, supplied by wirebonds. This represents a possible cost savings. An advantage of using wirebonding to supply the I/O and power and ground connections, rather than supplying such connections through a connected processing unit die, is that the processing unit dies would not then need the infrastructure required to provide power and additional I/Os that are not needed for the processing unit die itself, which additional infrastructure and associated overhead would likely increase the processing unit die area and significantly increase the processing unit cost. Also, if used without a satellite die this additional infrastructure in the processing unit would be wasted.
A step 310 of method 300 is to provide a substrate having a first side, an opposing second side, and a third side that extends from the first side to the second side. As an example, the substrate can be similar to substrate 110, and the first side, the second side, and the third side can be similar to, respectively, side 111, side 112, and side 213 of substrate 110. Sides 111 and 112 are first shown in
A step 320 of method 300 is to attach a first die to the first side of the substrate such that a portion of the first die extends beyond an edge of the first side of the substrate. As an example, the first die can be similar to die 120 that is first shown in
A step 330 of method 300 is to attach a second die to the first side of the substrate such that a portion of the second die extends beyond the edge of the first side of the substrate. As an example, the second die can be similar to die 130 that is first shown in
A step 340 of method 300 is to provide a bridge containing a plurality of electrically and/or optically conductive features. As an example, the bridge can be similar to bridge 140 that is first shown in
A step 350 of method 300 is to position the bridge adjacent to the third side of the substrate such that no portion of the substrate is underneath the bridge. This arrangement allows for a mechanical decoupling of the bridge and the substrate—materials that have a large mismatch in coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE). Furthermore, an unconstrained bridge could offer package stress benefits because it could move without creating a bending load on the fine-pitch joints. Thus, method 300 may not require the use of an underfill or encapsulant to fill the space around the bride in the aperture or slot or the like. As an example, step 350 may be accomplished using a pick and place machine, as known in the art.
A step 360 of method 300 is to attach the bridge to the first die and to the second die, thereby creating an electrical or optical connection between the first die and the second die. Accordingly, step 360 may constitute an attachment from the backside of the package, i.e., method 300 may constitute a “bridge last” process flow. It should be noted that because no portion of the substrate is underneath the bridge, this “bridge last” process flow may allow the use of a full-thickness bridge (unless thermomechanical considerations indicate bridge thinning to be advantageous for fine-pitch interconnect reliability, or unless thinning is needed for form factor or mechanical clearance) where other process flows would require that a thinned bridge be used. Also, the “bridge last” process flow enables the building of MCPs with dies or die stacks of disparate heights without any modification to the outlined assembly flow while also providing a scaleable solution that enables affordable assembly of multiple bridges in a given MCP configuration.
In one embodiment, step 360 may be accomplished using a thermocompression bonding process. In another embodiment, step 360 comprises using a solder reflow process. As is known in the art, in thermocompression bonding temperature and pressure may be controlled; with a solder reflow process only the temperature may be controlled. As is also known, solder reflow is a high-throughput batch process. Thermocompression bonding is typically a sequential process; however, a “ganged” bonder can process several units at once. Thermocompression bonding may in certain embodiments be needed to achieve the fine-pitch interconnect because of its process flexibility and its better control of process parameters.
A step 370 of method 300 is to attach the bridge to the substrate using a wirebond. As an example, the wirebond can be similar to wirebonds 241 that are shown in
As explained in further detail below, method 400 generally involves the attachment of dies to a carrier, fine pitch assembly of one or more bridges to the dies, coarse pitch assembly of the carrier, dies, and bridge(s) to a package substrate, and (optionally) de-bonding of the carrier. Potential advantages of this method over one or more of the other methods or embodiments described herein are that it eliminates the package substrate as a mechanical reference in the mixed-bump-pitch assembly flow, and that it forms the fine-pitch and coarser-pitch interconnects in separate steps. Furthermore, method 400 permits accurate bridge alignment in three dimensions. As stated above, accurate bridge alignment may be important in order to create an overall well-defined bump field for subsequent die attach. High interconnect densities accentuate this requirement.
A step 410 of method 400 is to attach a first die and a second die to a carrier. When placing the dies, suitable fiducials on previously placed dies or on other components of the subassembly, such as the carrier, may be used as a reference. As an example, the first die and the second die can be similar to, respectively, die 120 and die 130 that are first shown in
The carrier can be similar to a carrier 505 that is first shown in
A step 420 of method 400 is to attach a bridge to the first die and to the second die. Note that in this step only the fine pitch interconnect structures are attached. The small bump pitch may require highly accurate pick-and-place equipment. Again, on-die fiducials may be useful for achieving successful bonding. As an example, the bridge can be similar to bridge 140 that is first shown in
A step 430 of method 400 is to provide a substrate. As an example, the substrate can be similar to substrate 110 that is first shown in
As still another example, the substrate can be similar to a substrate 710 that is first shown in
A step 440 of method 400 is to attach the first die and the second die to the substrate. In this step only the die bumps with a large pitch (outside the bridge area) are attached. Since the bump pitch is large, less expensive pick-and-place equipment can typically be used. The appearance of multi-chip package 500 following the performance of step 440 is illustrated in
In some embodiments, step 440 is followed by the removal of the carrier. As an example, this may be accomplished by peeling, cutting, etching away, or melting the adhesive material, or otherwise de-bonding the carrier from the dies.
In yet another embodiment (not illustrated), in order to accommodate dies of different thicknesses, a mix of single dies and die stacks, or die stacks of different heights, the carrier or IHS may be stepped such that before bridge-to-die attach the bumps to be interconnected by an individual bridge are coplanar. Suitable steps or cavities can be created by machining the carrier or IHS.
A step 450 of method 400 is to attach the bridge to the substrate using a wirebond. As an example, the wirebond can be similar to wirebonds 241 that are shown in
An encapsulation material 945 at least partially surrounds bridge 940 in cavity 915 in the illustrated embodiment. As an example, substrate 910, die 920, die 930, and bridge 940 can be similar to, respectively, substrate 110, die 120, die 130, and bridge 140, all of which are first shown in
Die 920 has a portion 926 containing a plurality of interconnect structures 921 and a portion 927 containing a plurality of interconnect structures 922. Similarly, die 930 has a portion 936 containing a plurality of interconnect structures 931 and a portion 937 containing a plurality of interconnect structures 932. Interconnect structures 921 and 931 have a first (fine) pitch and interconnect structures 922 and 932 have a second (coarse) pitch that is different from the first pitch. Portions 926 and 936 are attached to the bridge (by way of fine pitch interconnect structures 921 and 931).
As has been discussed elsewhere herein, in some embodiments, such as, for example, where bridge 940 is an active die, bridge 940 is attached to substrate 910 using wirebonds. These wirebonds have not been depicted in
As explained in further detail below, method 1000 generally involves providing a package substrate, machining or otherwise forming a cavity for a silicon or other bridge, dispensing flux onto cavity floor pads, pick and place of the bridge with backside solder bumps, solder reflow with solder self-alignment of the bridge, deflux (unless a no-clean flux or fluxless attachment process is used), encapsulation of bridge, and assembly of active dies. A potential advantage of this process is that it is readily scalable to multiple bridges on a package and many substrates on a panel.
A step 1010 of method 1000 is to provide a substrate having a plurality of embedded pads. As an example, the substrate and the pads can be similar to, respectively, substrate 910 and pads 918 that are shown in
A step 1020 of method 1000 is to form a cavity in the substrate such that the pads are exposed at a floor of the cavity. As an example, the cavity can be similar to cavity 915 that is shown in
A step 1030 of method 1000 is to provide a bridge having bumps thereon corresponding to the pads. (Such correspondence between bumps and pads may, but does not necessarily, mean the number of bumps and the number of pads are equal to each other; rather, the correspondence is such that the bumps match up with the pads to the degree that a reliable mechanical joining is possible.) As an example, the bridge can be similar to bridge 940, shown in
A step 1040 of method 1000 is to place the bridge in the cavity and align the bumps and the pads to each other. Step 1040 attaches the bridge to the substrate. In one embodiment, the alignment of bumps and pads to each other is accomplished using the self-alignment of solder during reflow and joint formation. Solder self-alignment of electronic components where the surface tension of the liquid solder is the driving force is well known in the art. Careful design of a solder joint array can provide self alignment in the x and y dimensions with a positional tolerance in the order of 1 micrometer (hereinafter “micron” or “μm.”) Accurate alignment in the z dimension (height) can be achieved by control of the solder volume. The precisely aligned bridge may then be encapsulated, thereby locking the bridge at its precisely defined locations. The resulting hybrid package substrate may then be supplied to a die attach module.
A step 1050 of method 1000 is to provide a first die and a second die. As an example, the first die and the second die can be similar to, respectively, die 920 and die 930, both of which are shown in
A step 1060 of method 1000 is to attach the first die and the second die to the bridge and the substrate. In one embodiment, step 1060 comprises a flux dispense step, die pick-and-place steps, and a reflow step.
As mentioned elsewhere herein, at very high I/O densities and very fine bridge interconnect pitches, accurate alignment becomes important in order to facilitate a successful assembly of the MCP (die attach). Thus, in certain embodiments, and as shown in
A step 1070 of method 1000 is to attach the bridge to the substrate using a wirebond. As an example, the wirebond can be similar to wirebonds 241 that are shown in
As may be seen in the figure, multi-chip package 1100 is an example of an embodiment where a satellite die assembled in a hybrid manner is attached to a single on-package (processing unit) die. Such an arrangement allows for high-density, high-speed flip-chip connectivity between the processing unit and the satellite die and further allows for the processing unit die to utilize the functionality of the satellite die. In cases where high-density interconnects are not needed (e.g., because of the functionality of the satellite die), the flip-chip interconnects may have a relatively coarse pitch. Additional connections needed by the satellite die such as, but not limited to, power and ground connectivity, may be provided by wirebonds located on sides of the satellite die not obscured by the processing unit die.
In certain embodiments substrate 1110 contains a cavity in which active die 1130 is at least partially located. Such a cavity is visible in
Active die 1130 has a region 1138 and a region 1139, where region 1138 is an overlap region located between active die 1130 (below) and a portion of active die 1120 (above). As shown, the overlap region can be a partial overlap of active dies 1120 and 1130 such that the lower die is not completely underneath the upper die. The overlap region may be the location of one or more face-to-face flip-chip connections that electrically or optically connect the active dies to each other. Referring again to the illustrated embodiment, flip-chip connection 1131 is located in region 1138 while wirebonds 1141 are attached to active die 1130 in region 1139.
In the illustrated embodiment, active die 1130 is attached to substrate 1110 using wirebonds 1141. Note that one edge of active die 1130 is shown as having a double row of wirebonds. In some (non-illustrated) embodiments three or more wirebond rows may be fabricated. Such multiple rows, however, may not achieve the same fine pitches that are achievable with single rows, which may be as small as a pad pitch of 35 μm (corresponding to approximately 29 bonds/mm die edge). For power and ground connections, minimum pitch wirebond capability may not be needed and a thicker bond wire at a lower pitch may be acceptable or even favorable. It should be understood that the illustration, like all of the illustrations referred to herein, is not intended to be limiting, and that non-illustrated embodiments may employ more or fewer double wirebond rows (including embodiments having no such rows), one or more sections having more than two wirebond rows, longer or shorter rows having more or fewer wirebonds, wirebonds along only certain sides but not all sides of the active die, or any other useful wirebond configuration.
In one embodiment, active die 1120 is a processing unit die such as a central processing unit (CPU), a graphics processing unit (GPU), or the like, while active die 1130 is a satellite die with functionality such as memory (including volatile memory such as fast DRAM, external SRAM, eDRAM, and the like and non-volatile memory such as flash memory and the like), graphics processing, voltage regulation for power delivery, radio frequency (RF), or the like, including useful combinations thereof. A satellite die according to various embodiments could even be a microelectromechanical system (MEMS) chip, a sensor chip for use in a system-on-package (SoP), or a photonics die with optoelectronic functionality. Active die 1130 is sometimes referred to herein as a satellite die because it is connected to, and may share active functionality with, active die 1120. In certain embodiments, active die 1130 may also be connected to and share active functionality with one or more other dies (not illustrated in
In the illustrated embodiment, region 1138 further comprises a section 1203 that contains a plurality of flip-chip connections 1233 having a third density that is also less than the first density and can, in one embodiment, be the same as or substantially similar to the second density. The connections in any one or more of sections 1201, 1202, and 1203 can be used to enable active die 1120 access to the functionality of active die 1130, and vice versa. In the embodiment of
It was mentioned above that active die 1130 may be connected to one or more active dies in addition to active die 1120. In some embodiments, as also mentioned, active die 1130 acts as a bridge between active die 1120 and those additional active dies. Examples of this are depicted in
As illustrated in
A step 1410 of method 1400 is to provide a substrate. As an example, the substrate can be similar to substrate 1110 as it is shown in
A step 1420 of method 1400 is to attach a first active die to the substrate using a first flip-chip connection. As an example, the first active die and the first flip-chip connection can be similar to, respectively, active die 1120 and flip-chip connections 1121, both of which are shown in
A step 1430 of method 1400 is to attach a second active die to the first active die using a second flip-chip connection. As an example, the second active die and the second flip-chip connection can be similar to, respectively, active die 1130 and flip-chip connections 1131, both of which are first shown in
A step 1440 of method 1400 is to attach the second active die to the substrate. In one embodiment, the second active die is attached to the substrate using a wirebond such as wirebond 1141 that are first shown in
In the illustrated embodiment, active dies 1520 and 1550 have regions and sections the same as or similar to those described above in connection with active die 1120 and shown in
In certain embodiments substrate 1510 contains a cavity in which active die 1530 is at least partially located. Such a cavity is not visible in
A step 1710 of method 1700 is to provide a substrate. As an example, the substrate can be similar to substrate 1510 that is shown in
A step 1720 of method 1700 is to attach a first active die to the substrate using a first flip-chip connection. As an example, the first active die and the first flip-chip connection can be similar to, respectively, active die 1520 and flip-chip connections 1521, both of which are shown in
A step 1730 of method 1700 is to attach a second active die to the substrate using a second flip-chip connection. As an example, the second active die can be similar to active die 1550 and the second flip-chip connection can be similar to flip-chip connections 1551, both of which are shown in
A step 1740 of method 1700 is to attach the third active die to the first active die using a third flip-chip connection. As an example, the third flip-chip connection can be similar to flip-chip connections 1531 that are shown in
A step 1750 of method 1700 is to attach the third active die to the second active die using a fourth flip-chip connection. As an example, the fourth flip-chip connection can be similar to flip-chip connections 1552 that are shown in
A step 1760 of method 1700 is to attach the third active die to the substrate. In one embodiment, step 1760 comprises attaching the third active die to the substrate using wirebonds.
Although the invention has been described with reference to specific embodiments, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made without departing from the spirit or scope of the invention. Accordingly, the disclosure of embodiments of the invention is intended to be illustrative of the scope of the invention and is not intended to be limiting. It is intended that the scope of the invention shall be limited only to the extent required by the appended claims. For example, to one of ordinary skill in the art, it will be readily apparent that the multi-chip packages and the related structures and methods discussed herein may be implemented in a variety of embodiments, and that the foregoing discussion of certain of these embodiments does not necessarily represent a complete description of all possible embodiments.
Additionally, benefits, other advantages, and solutions to problems have been described with regard to specific embodiments. The benefits, advantages, solutions to problems, and any element or elements that may cause any benefit, advantage, or solution to occur or become more pronounced, however, are not to be construed as critical, required, or essential features or elements of any or all of the claims.
Moreover, embodiments and limitations disclosed herein are not dedicated to the public under the doctrine of dedication if the embodiments and/or limitations: (1) are not expressly claimed in the claims; and (2) are or are potentially equivalents of express elements and/or limitations in the claims under the doctrine of equivalents.
This application is a divisional of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 13/531,827 filed Jun. 25, 2012, which is a divisional of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 12/459,007, now U.S. Pat. No. 8,227,904, which was filed on Jun. 24, 2009.
Number | Date | Country | |
---|---|---|---|
Parent | 13531827 | Jun 2012 | US |
Child | 15876080 | US | |
Parent | 12459007 | Jun 2009 | US |
Child | 13531827 | US |